Showing posts with label alternate fluids. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alternate fluids. Show all posts
Friday, April 17, 2015
Waterjetting 32b - early work with polymers
If we lower the viscosity of the fluid in a jet hitting a target, then the jet can penetrate into the fissures and flaws of that surface more easily and in this way it will see an improved cutting performance. On the other hand the thinner fluids have less resistance to the air or other fluids through which the jet has to pass on its way from the nozzle to the target, and so the amount of energy that is delivered to the target can be lower than with a less viscose jet. Some of the changes in fluid chemistry can, however, be reached using small amounts of different chemical additives that can have quite a profound effect on performance without totally changing the fluid being used.
Consider that before the jet gets to the nozzle it has already completed most of the journey from the pump to the target. And along the way, as I pointed out in one of the earlier posts I wrote, pressure losses along the line, due largely to friction, can overwhelm the power supplied by the pump. There was an occasion where a colleague at another research group was running a system where, because of the small diameter of the tubing he was using, the pressure drop from the pump was more than 75% before the water even left the nozzle. A slight increase in tubing diameter would have made the system much more powerful, with no other increase in cost.
But sometimes that option isn’t really available. I remember my first introduction to the use of long-chain polymers was after reading an article in The Sunday Times which described an investigation by the New York Fire Department. One of the problems in fighting high-rise fires is that the firemen have to haul their hoses up the long flights of stairs and 2-inch diameter hoses become quite heavy as they are moved up from level to level. In the late 1960’s (in the administration of Mayor John Lindsay) tests were carried out to see if this could be improved. Normally, when a smaller 1.5 inch diameter hose was used, the pressure loss in pumping 100 gpm through 1.5-inch diameter hose is around 25 psi per hundred feet, with 98% of that loss being due to the turbulence of the water.
Figure 1. Demonstration of the benefit of polymers before John Lindsey, the Mayor of New York City (seated far right). May 13, 1969. The two jets are of equal size and fed from pumps at the same pressure. The jet barely reaching the holding tank is the standard water, the other contains polyox.
What the demonstration showed was that more water could be sent through the smaller hose, (roughly 70%) so that it could be used, instead of the larger hose, and with better effect on putting out nearby fires.
One interesting historical comment is that the demonstration occurred in 1969, however back at the University of Leeds, I was aware of the research in 1967, and had included, as chapter 5 of my dissertation, a study of the benefits of using the polymer. Similarly Dr. Norman Franz, then at the University of Michigan, (and thereafter at UBC) had also become aware of the work, and – being smarter – had patented his findings, that were then licensed by the fore-runner (McCartney Manufacturing Company) of KMT.
The benefits were not just that the polymer reduced friction in the line from the pump, transitioning the flow from turbulent to laminar, with the consequent reduction in friction losses, but these also extended beyond the nozzle. I have always suggested that the easiest way to think of this is to compare the benefits of using the polymers to that of picking up spaghetti from a plate. Very short strands of the pasta need the eater to use a spoon, or simple fork to try and grab a small amount for a bite. On the other hand, where the pasta strands are longer, and well mixed together, when one pulls one out of the pile it is attached to another few that also rise, and before long the fork is full of a seemingly endless set of attached strands.
Given that the molecular weight of Polymerized Ethylene Oxide (Polyox) (which was first introduced by Union Carbide and is now a Dow product) can range up into the 8 million range, it is easy to make the analogy. As a result the intertwining of the long molecules facilitates passage down the feed line, but also tends to maintain the jet coherence once it leaves the nozzle.
The jet is thus not only allowed to pass through the feed line at a lower (often significantly so) pressure loss than with conventional water, but also, once the jet leaves the nozzle, the stream remains coherent to a much greater distance. This can be seen in Figure 1 at low pressure, however that result has been similarly validated at pressure of up to 50 ksi in the years since that original work was completed.
Figure 2. Effect of adding a small amount of polymer to the cutting performance of a jet at 10,000 psi.
I will spend the next couple of posts discussing the general concept of polymer additions but will close this with another anecdote. After I had carried out the first test series – which yielded the graph shown in Figure 2, I wrote to Union Carbide, who had been kind enough to send me about half-a-pound of dry product for that study. Given the favorable results we wanted to expand the study – but I received a note back from the European sales office of the company, together with an additional box of roughly three-quarters of a pound of product. The note let me know that I had now received their entire allocation of product for the continent of Europe, and that, in consequence, my research needed to be conservative from thereon out, since there was unlikely to be any more supply for some considerable time. (Which was why the research could not be pursued at any greater length until I had moved to UMR and acquired my own system – which took an additional four years).
It was not until years later, as spreadsheets became ubiquitous, and data analysis facilitated from the hand-calculations that we were reduced to before the days of computers, that I was finally able to fully comprehend the data that we had, but I will leave that discussion until the next post.
Consider that before the jet gets to the nozzle it has already completed most of the journey from the pump to the target. And along the way, as I pointed out in one of the earlier posts I wrote, pressure losses along the line, due largely to friction, can overwhelm the power supplied by the pump. There was an occasion where a colleague at another research group was running a system where, because of the small diameter of the tubing he was using, the pressure drop from the pump was more than 75% before the water even left the nozzle. A slight increase in tubing diameter would have made the system much more powerful, with no other increase in cost.
But sometimes that option isn’t really available. I remember my first introduction to the use of long-chain polymers was after reading an article in The Sunday Times which described an investigation by the New York Fire Department. One of the problems in fighting high-rise fires is that the firemen have to haul their hoses up the long flights of stairs and 2-inch diameter hoses become quite heavy as they are moved up from level to level. In the late 1960’s (in the administration of Mayor John Lindsay) tests were carried out to see if this could be improved. Normally, when a smaller 1.5 inch diameter hose was used, the pressure loss in pumping 100 gpm through 1.5-inch diameter hose is around 25 psi per hundred feet, with 98% of that loss being due to the turbulence of the water.
Figure 1. Demonstration of the benefit of polymers before John Lindsey, the Mayor of New York City (seated far right). May 13, 1969. The two jets are of equal size and fed from pumps at the same pressure. The jet barely reaching the holding tank is the standard water, the other contains polyox.
What the demonstration showed was that more water could be sent through the smaller hose, (roughly 70%) so that it could be used, instead of the larger hose, and with better effect on putting out nearby fires.
One interesting historical comment is that the demonstration occurred in 1969, however back at the University of Leeds, I was aware of the research in 1967, and had included, as chapter 5 of my dissertation, a study of the benefits of using the polymer. Similarly Dr. Norman Franz, then at the University of Michigan, (and thereafter at UBC) had also become aware of the work, and – being smarter – had patented his findings, that were then licensed by the fore-runner (McCartney Manufacturing Company) of KMT.
The benefits were not just that the polymer reduced friction in the line from the pump, transitioning the flow from turbulent to laminar, with the consequent reduction in friction losses, but these also extended beyond the nozzle. I have always suggested that the easiest way to think of this is to compare the benefits of using the polymers to that of picking up spaghetti from a plate. Very short strands of the pasta need the eater to use a spoon, or simple fork to try and grab a small amount for a bite. On the other hand, where the pasta strands are longer, and well mixed together, when one pulls one out of the pile it is attached to another few that also rise, and before long the fork is full of a seemingly endless set of attached strands.
Given that the molecular weight of Polymerized Ethylene Oxide (Polyox) (which was first introduced by Union Carbide and is now a Dow product) can range up into the 8 million range, it is easy to make the analogy. As a result the intertwining of the long molecules facilitates passage down the feed line, but also tends to maintain the jet coherence once it leaves the nozzle.
The jet is thus not only allowed to pass through the feed line at a lower (often significantly so) pressure loss than with conventional water, but also, once the jet leaves the nozzle, the stream remains coherent to a much greater distance. This can be seen in Figure 1 at low pressure, however that result has been similarly validated at pressure of up to 50 ksi in the years since that original work was completed.
Figure 2. Effect of adding a small amount of polymer to the cutting performance of a jet at 10,000 psi.
I will spend the next couple of posts discussing the general concept of polymer additions but will close this with another anecdote. After I had carried out the first test series – which yielded the graph shown in Figure 2, I wrote to Union Carbide, who had been kind enough to send me about half-a-pound of dry product for that study. Given the favorable results we wanted to expand the study – but I received a note back from the European sales office of the company, together with an additional box of roughly three-quarters of a pound of product. The note let me know that I had now received their entire allocation of product for the continent of Europe, and that, in consequence, my research needed to be conservative from thereon out, since there was unlikely to be any more supply for some considerable time. (Which was why the research could not be pursued at any greater length until I had moved to UMR and acquired my own system – which took an additional four years).
It was not until years later, as spreadsheets became ubiquitous, and data analysis facilitated from the hand-calculations that we were reduced to before the days of computers, that I was finally able to fully comprehend the data that we had, but I will leave that discussion until the next post.
Read more!
Wednesday, April 8, 2015
Waterjetting 32a - jet fluids
From time to time I am asked why we use water in almost every application of high-pressure waterjet use, rather than using any one of a number of other choices for the fluid. There are a couple of major reasons for this. The first is that most of the uses of the tool will require that we use a fairly large quantity of fluid, over time, and water is the cheapest and most readily available of the alternatives that can be used in such volumes. The other is that, in many circumstances, it works as well, if not better than those alternatives. As an additional point it can often be cleaned up relatively cheaply and simply before being disposed of after use.
But the conclusion isn’t an absolutely true one, and along the way there have been a number of different investigations to find alternatives that can provide a better answer than just water alone. Some of these choices suggest applications where a different fluid might work better, for example if the target is a food product that contains a lot of sugar then it might be better to cut with a form of vegetable oil that does not dissolve the sugar on contact. In other cases there is an advantage to adding a chemical to the water to change its properties.
The changes in performance that decide whether the change in cutting fluid is worth the effort are (as with so many other choices) going to be based on the particular job that has to be carried out. In some cases, as with cutting candy for example, the benefits of using an oil stream may make the process practical in a food that would otherwise not be feasible to be cut with a high-pressure jet, for aesthetic reasons if no other.
Figure 1. Effect of changing fluid properties on cut depth at an impact velocity of 330 ft/sec. (after Rochester and Brunton) on a nickel target.
Several different fluids were used to generate the curves shown in Figure 1, ranging up to mercury in density, and including four different oils as a way of investigating viscosity.
One of the down sides to the use of oil as a cutting fluid comes from the increased viscosity of the fluid, with some of the oils that were initially used as the tool went into commercial use for cutting confectionary items.
The increased viscosity of the oil raised the pressure required to drive the fluid from the pump through the delivery lines to the cutting nozzle arrays. This in turn lowered the cutting pressure at the nozzle, and made the differential between the operating pressure at the pump during the drive stroke and during the reversal significantly greater. This greater fluctuation in pressure produced a greater fatigue on the drive train, and in turn led to a more rapid failure of components within the system. While the initial answer was thought to be in using a different cutting oil, the final, easier, solution was to move the pump closer to the cutting zone, reducing the pressure losses and bringing the fatigue back to acceptable levels.
Changing fluid properties can therefore have a significant impact on system operation, even though they may have little impact on the actual cutting performance, although in many cases there are significant changes as the fluid properties are changed.
The chemical impact is one that is perhaps addressed more commonly in cleaning applications, where it is often suggested that chemical agents be added to the water as a way of weakening the bond between dirt and the underlying surface. While this is theoretically possible, it should be remembered that the jet, even at the relatively low pressure of most pressure washers and car wash units, will be travelling at speeds of hundreds of feet per second. The residence time of the chemical on the surface can thus be measured in milliseconds and is rarely long enough for much change to occur.
In these circumstances it is usually more fruitful (and less demanding of chemical) to spray the chemical cleaning solution onto the surface first, and then allow a short period of time for the interaction to fully occur before applying the pressure wash. In these conditions (as we saw when we watched as our house was pressure washed the other week) even though the nozzle was held too far from the surface for there to be much pressure on the wall by the time the jet reached it, the chemical cleaner had broken the bonds of the algae and dirt, and the house walls were rapidly cleaned with relatively little additional effort. (This is contrast with the time that I had cleaned it without chemical, where it was necessary to keep the nozzle within six inches of the wall for the jet, unassisted, to remove all the surface contamination).
In the case of a house cleaning this highlights an additional benefit from using the chemical, since the lower pressure jet impact on the building means that the jet will not be strong enough to erode any of the timber surfaces around the house that were starting to weather with the passage of time.
There are, however, some chemicals that are used in mining and civil construction that will interact relatively quickly, when introduced into the cracks within rocks, particularly if they can be pushed to the tips of the cracks where they can rapidly reduce the strength of the bonds across the tip of the crack, making it easier for the crack to grow at lower fluid pressures. The fluid characteristic that controls this effectiveness is often related to its Zeta Potential. However much discussion of that topic would rapidly take us a considerable distance from the current subject, and so I would recommend that any of those interested might want to follow along a line that might start with the work at Brookhaven.
This series will return with a look at some of the mechanical changes that can be made to a waterjet, to improve cutting of everything from shoes, to ships and similar subjects.
Rochester M. and Brunton J. The Influence of the Physical Properties of the Fluid on the Erosion of Solids, CVED/C-MAT/TR10, University of Cambridge, UK 1973. (This formed part of Mike’s doctoral dissertation).
But the conclusion isn’t an absolutely true one, and along the way there have been a number of different investigations to find alternatives that can provide a better answer than just water alone. Some of these choices suggest applications where a different fluid might work better, for example if the target is a food product that contains a lot of sugar then it might be better to cut with a form of vegetable oil that does not dissolve the sugar on contact. In other cases there is an advantage to adding a chemical to the water to change its properties.
The changes in performance that decide whether the change in cutting fluid is worth the effort are (as with so many other choices) going to be based on the particular job that has to be carried out. In some cases, as with cutting candy for example, the benefits of using an oil stream may make the process practical in a food that would otherwise not be feasible to be cut with a high-pressure jet, for aesthetic reasons if no other.
Figure 1. Effect of changing fluid properties on cut depth at an impact velocity of 330 ft/sec. (after Rochester and Brunton) on a nickel target.
Several different fluids were used to generate the curves shown in Figure 1, ranging up to mercury in density, and including four different oils as a way of investigating viscosity.
One of the down sides to the use of oil as a cutting fluid comes from the increased viscosity of the fluid, with some of the oils that were initially used as the tool went into commercial use for cutting confectionary items.
The increased viscosity of the oil raised the pressure required to drive the fluid from the pump through the delivery lines to the cutting nozzle arrays. This in turn lowered the cutting pressure at the nozzle, and made the differential between the operating pressure at the pump during the drive stroke and during the reversal significantly greater. This greater fluctuation in pressure produced a greater fatigue on the drive train, and in turn led to a more rapid failure of components within the system. While the initial answer was thought to be in using a different cutting oil, the final, easier, solution was to move the pump closer to the cutting zone, reducing the pressure losses and bringing the fatigue back to acceptable levels.
Changing fluid properties can therefore have a significant impact on system operation, even though they may have little impact on the actual cutting performance, although in many cases there are significant changes as the fluid properties are changed.
The chemical impact is one that is perhaps addressed more commonly in cleaning applications, where it is often suggested that chemical agents be added to the water as a way of weakening the bond between dirt and the underlying surface. While this is theoretically possible, it should be remembered that the jet, even at the relatively low pressure of most pressure washers and car wash units, will be travelling at speeds of hundreds of feet per second. The residence time of the chemical on the surface can thus be measured in milliseconds and is rarely long enough for much change to occur.
In these circumstances it is usually more fruitful (and less demanding of chemical) to spray the chemical cleaning solution onto the surface first, and then allow a short period of time for the interaction to fully occur before applying the pressure wash. In these conditions (as we saw when we watched as our house was pressure washed the other week) even though the nozzle was held too far from the surface for there to be much pressure on the wall by the time the jet reached it, the chemical cleaner had broken the bonds of the algae and dirt, and the house walls were rapidly cleaned with relatively little additional effort. (This is contrast with the time that I had cleaned it without chemical, where it was necessary to keep the nozzle within six inches of the wall for the jet, unassisted, to remove all the surface contamination).
In the case of a house cleaning this highlights an additional benefit from using the chemical, since the lower pressure jet impact on the building means that the jet will not be strong enough to erode any of the timber surfaces around the house that were starting to weather with the passage of time.
There are, however, some chemicals that are used in mining and civil construction that will interact relatively quickly, when introduced into the cracks within rocks, particularly if they can be pushed to the tips of the cracks where they can rapidly reduce the strength of the bonds across the tip of the crack, making it easier for the crack to grow at lower fluid pressures. The fluid characteristic that controls this effectiveness is often related to its Zeta Potential. However much discussion of that topic would rapidly take us a considerable distance from the current subject, and so I would recommend that any of those interested might want to follow along a line that might start with the work at Brookhaven.
This series will return with a look at some of the mechanical changes that can be made to a waterjet, to improve cutting of everything from shoes, to ships and similar subjects.
Rochester M. and Brunton J. The Influence of the Physical Properties of the Fluid on the Erosion of Solids, CVED/C-MAT/TR10, University of Cambridge, UK 1973. (This formed part of Mike’s doctoral dissertation).
Read more!
Labels:
alternate fluids,
Brunton,
Cambridge,
cleaning,
cutting candy,
jet density,
nickel,
oil jets,
Rochester,
viscosity
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


