Showing posts with label SST. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SST. Show all posts

Monday, December 12, 2011

AMO, NAO and predicting Atlantic Coast temperatures

Several months ago, after finishing the individual state temperature evaluations, I started putting the state data together in regional groups, starting with the Atlantic States. What motivated that start was the discovery that, along the East Coast, the individual states all displayed a drop in temperature, over the period from about 1950 to 1965 on the order of 4 degrees F. This was a surprisingly large number, in terms of the consistency over both space and time, with which the fall in temperature occurred. But there was some physical evidence of the impact of these changes since, following a piece on bird populations, it was possible to tie the fall in temperture to the migration of the Black Capped Chickadee, as an example, which moved south as the temperature fell, appearing for the first time in North Carolina at the height of the cold spell. When the average plot for all the states (excluding Florida) was derived the average fall was reduced to about 3 degrees F, with the drop in temperature reducing for states further South.

Averaged Time of Observation corrected (TOBS) temperatures for the Atlantic states, with state averages weighted by area in the overall average of the data.

Today’s post shows how this can now be explained, and how it might, from existing data, be possible to predict the future shape of this plot.

Looking at the range of states over which this fall occurred it was clear that it while the temperature drop made it across the Adirondacks into the Midwest it got no further and the Midwest had some differences in the pattern of temperature recovery. The weather normally travels from West to East, and so the logical cause seemed to be to look first at what happened in the Pacific, to see if US temperature variations could be explained.

Over the last couple of weeks this has taken the course of looking at the impact of the El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO) with its roughly 5-year cycle, first on regional temperatures and then on that of the individual states. While changes in the ENSO impacts moisture and drought patterns in the states, it did not, comparing temperatures, seem to have as great an impact on the temperatures along the West Coast, where the current flows impact. And further it was restricted to coastal states, in what correlation was immediately visible.

Coming back to the Atlantic Coast there is a similar oscillation in the sea surface temperatures (SST) called the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO). Looking at a plot of this average over time, it is immediately clear that there is a concurrent drop in these temperatures, in around the same time period, that might answer the question at to what had caused the temperature drop along the East Coast.

Sea Surface Temperatures in the Atlantic showing the AMO (NOAA )

One can then, in the same way as for the Pacific Coast States, overlay this curve on the average of the Atlantic States variation (with the Midwest added to show the limit of range) to validate the above statement. However in the first step the overlay was kept at the same vertical scale, so that the size of the anomaly in SST’s that forms the oscillation, could be compared with the size of the temperature changes on land.

Comparison of the fluctuation in AMO anomaly with the temperatures on the Atlantic and Midwest regions. Note that the AMO plot has been scaled and randomly placed vertically to allow distinction from the two other curves.

The immediate first observation is that the land temperatures have fluctuated over twice the scale (roughly) of the SST values, though it should be remembered that the latter are averaged over a much greater area.

Looking over the entire history of the temperature record, which for now is taken as post 1895, the plot for AMO values is doubled, to make it easier to see how the peaks and troughs may coincide, and then 52 deg F as added to the anomaly values to set them below the Atlantic States, and the values are averaged for each year.

Comparison of the form of the AMO (which has been doubled in size) with the changes in the average temperatures of the Atlantic States over the past 112 years.

So now the question comes as to the cause of the changes in the AMO, and one finds that this is currently a work in progress. The AMO itself was only described in 1994, and work on what is the cause, and what it correlates to is ongoing. But there are are several different other cycles in the Atlantic, and it is interesting to see what folk have already found by way of correlation.

One of these other cycles is the drift of the InterTropical Convergence Zone, or ITCZ. Back when I was reading “Stories for Boys” about sailing ships in the Atlantic the ITCZ was called the “Doldrums.”

Location and characteristics of the ITCZ (Da Silva 1994 ).

The Doldrums drift North in the summer. However the movement and nature of the ITCZ behavior has been suggested to be dependent on the AMO, rather than the cause (see for example Knight, Folland and Scaife)

What is actually more interesting, particularly from the “climate prophet” point of view is a suggested correlation with another Atlantic Cycle, that of the North Atlantic Oscillation.
North Atlantic Oscillation – NAO is defined as the fluctuation in the difference of atmospheric pressure at the sea level between two specific locations: Ponta Delgada, Azores and Stykkisholmur/Reykjavik.
Although the NAO is now undergoing a name change to the Northern Annular Mode, the relevant changes in atmospheric pressure (which are shown in color and globally at the Climate Prediction Center can be illustrated, to allow easier layman comprehension with this picture from JISAO).

Pressure patterns in the North Atlantic showing the pressure difference that builds up to value the NOA. (JISAO via Gosselin)

Comes now this new paper from Vukcevic which suggests that there is a correlation between the AMO and the NAO, but that the correlation becomes much better if the values for the NAO are delayed by eleven years. Further that the correlation becomes better when only the fluctuations in the pressures at Reykjavik are considered.

Correlation between an eleven year lagged Icelandic pressure and the 3 year moving average SSTs in the Atlantic – the AMO. (Vukcevic )

What is riveting about this is the current correlation not only the AMO and NAO, but that it is time lagged. And as Vukcevic notes, there is an eleven year time lag between the behavior of parts of the NAO and the consequent change in the AMO. Which means, if this is correct, then we know what the future behavior of the AMO is going to be, since the end of the red line above indicates the SST trends over the next eleven years. That in turn, as was shown earlier, means that the temperature trends for the Atlantic Coast can also be surmised for the next eleven years, and as has been noted elsewhere this holds true not only for the United States but also Europe in that the NAO also has been shown to influence the Central English Temperature (CET).

This is obviously quite intriguing and will no doubt be the object of some discussion over the next few months, particularly since a second paper is promised. It is unlikely that it is the drop in pressure itself that is the cause, but it is conceivable that this is an indicator (dare one say proxy) for some other event and as such it is indicating how this other forcing event is behaving, and through that route becomes a marker itself for the temperature changes that are coming. But then that raises the question as to what it is a proxy for?

Read more!

Saturday, August 6, 2011

Maryland combined temperatures

Moving up the East Coast from Virginia, the next state is Maryland, where I will look to answer the continuing question on whether it too is showing the significant drop in temperature that seems to hold along the Atlantic Coast from around 1948 to the late 1960’s. It was not evident in the first temperature plot that I made for Missouri when I began this series, and only drew my attention as I reached states along the Atlantic Coast.

USHCN stations in Maryland (CDIAC)

Maryland has 16 USHCN stations from Beltsville to another Woodstock. It is interesting that there are two stations that are far to the west in the state, while all the rest lie relatively close to the coast. So I’ll come back to that point a little later in the post. Oh, and there is still that problem at the CDIAC site:



Mayland has one GISS station on the list, in Baltimore. And there are two Baltimore entries on the GISS site, one runs from 1895 to 2006 (Baltimore WSO City) and one from 1950 to date (Baltimore Blt/Washington International). It is, of course, the latter that has the correct co-ordinates for the current single GISS location that they use. I say of course since this (truncated station data) has been a common discovery as I have moved through the individual states. I had a look at the longer time record station and it does not show that temperature drop that I mentioned at the beginning of the post.

Historic temperature data for Baltimore MD, as recorded at the GISS station no longer used by them.

In contrast the site that has been retained does clearly show the drop in average annual temperature, from 13.67 deg C in 1953 down to 11.85 deg C in 1963, (a drop of 1.82 deg C, 3.3 deg F) consistent in size with the temperature drops seen further south.


Annual temperatures as reported by GISS for the station in Baltimore MD.

Interestingly one of the USHCN stations is located at the Maryland Science Center in Baltimore, and when one looks at the homogenized data for that site, the temperature drop is much less easily discerned:

USHCN homogenized temperatures for the MD Science Center in Baltimore (CDIAC)

And when the Time of Observation corrected raw data is examined there is no discernable drop, suggesting perhaps that the phenomenon is closely related to changes in the Sea Surface Temperature (SST) over that time interval, since the Science Center is surrounded by Baltimore.

Time of Observation corrected (TOBS) temperatures for the MD Science Center in Baltimore over the period where other states show a fall in temperature.

If I turn to the state as a whole, there is a difference between the sole GISS station temperature and that of the average of the USHCN stations, even with the homogenized data and the shorter time interval.

Difference between the GISS temperature for Maryland and the average of the homogenized USHCN station temperatures, in the interval where the GISS station has been functioning.

For the state as a whole, the data shows the three dgree drop in temperatures, both for the homogenized data, and for the TOBS values. The difference in temperature rise for both is relatively similar 1.59 deg F per century for the TOBS temperatures and 1.69 deg F for the homogenized. Given the strong influence of the adjacent ocean this is not perhaps surprising.

Average temperature for the state of Maryland over the years, from the TOBS data averaged for the stations in the state.

The two stations over on the far west of the state (Cumberland and Oakland) are also at a much greater elevation, however when I averaged the two over the same interval I get that same drop in temperature that I have been discussing.

Fall in temperature in the period from 1940’s through the 1960’s for the two western stations in Maryland, averaged TOBS data.

Maryland is 250 miles long and 90 miles wide, lying between 75.07 deg W and 79.55 deg W, and 37.88 deg N and 39.72 deg N. The mean latitude is sensibly 39.5 deg N. The USHCN average latitude is 39 deg N, and for the GISS station 39.28 deg N. The elevation rises from sea-level to 1,024 m, with the mean being 107 m. The USHCN average is 97.5 m, while the GISS station is only 6.1 m above the sea.

Looking at the way in which geography changes the temperatures around the state.

Variation in station temperature with latitude in Maryland (TOBS data)

Variation in station temperature with longitude in Maryland (TOBS data)

Variation in station temperature with elevation in Maryland (TOBS data)

Seeking information on populations around the various stations, Royal Oak didn’t appear in the citi-data list, and so I used the zip-codes site to get 483. Woodstock is a suburb of Baltimore, and is folded into Baltimore I suspect, so I again used the zip-codes site to get a population of 7,192.

Variation in station temperature with adjacent population in Maryland (TOBS data)

It dawns on me that the difference between the homogenized and TOBS data is generally quite small the closer we get to the present, and this should mean that ther should be a correlation with homogenized data, now that I am only using the past five years of temperature data to correlate with relatively recent population. (I wrote this before plotting the final graph).

Variation in station temperature with adjacent population in Maryland (using USHCN homogenized data)

And finally there is



Maybe I was being a little optimistic.

Read more!

Saturday, July 16, 2011

North Carolina combined temperatures

The last post in this series, on South Carolina, brought up an unexpected temperature variation that, coincidentally, was being discussed both at Real Climate and at Climate Audit. The controversy at those two sites relates to the dip in sea surface temperatures (SST's) prior to 1970, and how accurately these were measured with the controversy relating to how many ships used a thermometer stuck into a bucket to measure the temperature, and how many used a measure of the temperature made at the inlet for the engine cooling water. Not wishing to step into that argument at the moment, what is interesting to me is that while the temperatures in Georgia and South Carolina showed a drop in temperatures over the same period and a quick check shows some drop in Maine, and Vermont, but looking at Massachusetts it seems more that the higher temperatures of around 1950 are the aberrant ones. But these are land-based and therefore not subject to the variations based on how the water was collected and held. So we will see how this pans out for North Carolina.

Location of the USHCN stations in North Carolina

North Carolina has the same number of USHCN stations as South Carolina (29) but it also has four GISS stations (whereas SC had none). The four stations are at Asheville (with data from 1903, a complete set from Charlotte, Greensboro has only data from 1948 on, and Raleigh. The average of the GISS stations shows the same drop that occurred in the states further South.

Average temperature in the state of North Carolina as a function of time, using the GISS station average.

Comparing this to the homogenized data from the stations in the USHCN, the drop is found, using the larger number of stations in that set of stations.

Average temperature in the state of North Carolina as a function of time, using the USHCN homogenized temperature average.

Average temperature in the state of North Carolina as a function of time, using the Time of Observation (TOBS) adjusted raw temperature average.

North Carolina is some 500 miles long and 130 miles wide. It runs from 75.5 deg W to 84.25 deg W, and from 34 deg N to 36.35 deg N. The central latitude is at 35.60 deg N. That of the GISS stations is at 35.65 deg N, while the USHCN is at 35.6 deg N. The state rises from sea level to 2,037 m, with a mean elevation of 213.4 m. The average GISS location is at 312.7 m, while that of the USHCN stations is at 260 m.

Looking to find the population around the different stations, Cape Hatteras is more the name of the barrier island than the community, so I checked with Google Earth:

Location of the USHCN station on Cape Hatteras near Frisco.

Frisco, checking with U.S. Beacon has a population of 401, though that was in 2000 and seems, from the photo, to be low.

And Transou does not appear in citi-data, so I also went to Google Earth for it. Looking around I decided it should have a population of about 50, although it turns out to be relatively close to Laurel Springs (population 1,400).

Location of Transou station in North Carolina – while there are lots of plots ready for housing development there are not a lot of houses yet.

The population around the GISS stations averages 361,732, while that of the USHCN stations is 61,431. That population difference might have caused a 0.47 deg difference making the GISS temperatures higher, while the difference is actually 0.22 degrees. That would be more than explained (about 0.5 deg) by the difference in elevation between the two averages.

Looking at the changes in temperature with location, North Carolina has the usual relationship with latitude:

Effect of latitude on average annual temperature in North Carolina

The state rises fairly significantly to the west:

Effect of longitude on average annual temperature in North Carolina

However the temperature fall is more likely correlated with elevation (since it goes down on the other side of the mountains).

Effect of elevation on average annual temperature in North Carolina

Looking at the population effect, and considering the average temperature over the past 5 years as the dependent variable:

Effect of local population on average temperature in North Carolina

Well it seems clear that the steep drop in temperatures around 1950 occurred in North Carolina also, so does it still hold true further north?

Oh, and that drop does not show up when one subtracts the TOBS data from the homogenized USHCN values, that adjustment is more linear.



Read more!

Saturday, August 28, 2010

California temperatures, the TOBS data

Back in April I first commented on the historic California temperature changes, using the homogenized data then available from the USHCN. Since then they have posted both the raw data and that corrected for Time of Observation (TOBS), as well as the data that has been adjusted to apply other perceived corrections. At the moment I am going back and seeing how the TOBS data is changed by those corrections. So this will examine that data, using the same form as originally. (Note that following the comment by Kinuachdrach the evaluation of Death Valley at the bottom of the piece has been UPDATED).

So first I go to the US Historical Climatology Network and download the 54 station set of data (there will be a short pause while I do this). And then there are the four GISS stations whose data we got the first time around (we aren’t going into those adjustments at this time). Looking at the difference between the few GISS stations and the average for the USHCN set it is interesting to note that while the GISS stations got successively warmer than the state average, in the raw data the reverse was the case, although the decline was very small.



The average difference between the two sets is 1.63 deg, which is the same as for the homogenized data. For the state as a whole, over the past 115 years there has been a steady warming trend, though the raw data suggests an average increase of 2 deg F per century, while the homogenized data suggests only 1.3 deg.


Looking at the effects of geography, there is the correlation with latitude:


There is virtually no change in the relationship of temperature with latitude, though there is sensibly no correlation with longitude, similar to the result with the homogenized data.


Given that California goes all the way to the sea, the effects of elevation should be significant, and in both cases they are.


The regression is a little higher than with the homogenized data (r^2 0.4) but otherwise they are much the same. Which speaks for having a significant number of stations in the state, since there were a significant number of years where there were dropped data from several of the stations. This becomes obvious as the standard deviation shows that scatter getting worse as the collective number of stations reporting peaked. Interesting with the raw data it is leveling off, whereas it was getting worse when the data was homogenized.


And even having to make some assumptions about the number of inhabitants of some of the more remote stations there is still a logarithmic correlation with population.


The correlation is slightly worse however (it was 0.10).

And just for grins, this is what has been happening in Death Valley, and it looks as though that has been getting hotter too.


California was the first state that I have looked at that was on the coast, and so it will be interesting to see if there is a coastal effect and define what it is, and how far inland it stretches. But for that we need more data.

Kinuachdrach made a comment on the Death Valley data (see below) and so I went to see what the condition of the weather station was, and discovered something that I thought readers might find of as much interest as I did. The full story is at the reference by John Daly.

There are, actually, two weather stations now in Death Valley, where the all-time highest temperature in the United States was recorded on July 10th, 1913, at 57 degC. Using the GISS data for California, the plot that is given is this:

And the site has a plaque that says:
"During the summer of 1998 - the warmest year on record - we recorded the hottest air temperature anywhere in the world of 53.06°C ±0.1°C (128°F) on 17 July 1998 at 3:15 pm local standard time."
Since the GISS plot stops before that, I am, being curious, just going to go to the GISS Site and download the latest version of the graph:


Note that since the high temperatures were single days, and the data plotted is the average for the year the records aren't evident. However the station was apparently changed in the 1990's to give the record at Badwater, rather than the earlier data that was recorded at Furnace Creek, according to John Daly. The differences are, among others, that Badwater (as documented) is more of a sun trap than the old station, 20 miles away out in the open, at Furnace Creek.

But it is worth commenting that over at Watts Up With That, Steve Goddard has noted that there seems to be some work on re-adjusting the data back to 1998 that removes the overall high temperature that they showed then (and which agreed with other records) in favor of lowering that temperature so that the overall graph now shows a steady increase in temperature over the last three decades (which does not agree with other records). So when I show you the GISS record (which as with the USHCN data is modified from the original raw data) until I have worked out (or more likely someone else has) what was done with that data before it was plotted, all I can give you is what is on the record. And in this case, I suspect it is only a part of a continuing story.

Read more!