Tuesday, June 9, 2009

The hydrofracing bill, ANWR and offshore drilling

A couple more quick notes for the evening: the bill to move hydrofracing under the Clean Water Act and about which I summarized the hearing last week, was put forward today.
Democratic Representatives Diana DeGette, Maurice Hinchey and Jared Polis offered a bill that would reverse a 2005 measure that excluded hydraulic fracturing from regulation under the Safe Drinking Water Act.

In the Senate, Democrat Bob Casey introduced similar legislation
.
While the initial intent, as commented by Congresswoman DeGette at the hearing last week was purportedly just to have the chemicals included in the hydrofrac reported, under the rules of the Safe Drinking Water Act, the impacts on the supply of natural gas, which relies on hydrofracing to release the gas in the gas shales, is also going to be a consequence. The API highlighted an IHS report that concluded that:
additional federal regulations would lower the number of US wells drilled by more than 20% over a five-year period, while cutting natural gas production by about 10% from last year’s levels by 2014.
That does not seem to concern the bill’s authors who seemed to have a much more severe impact in mind.
"It's time to fix an unfortunate chapter in the Bush administration's energy policy and close the 'Halliburton loophole' that has enabled energy companies to pump enormous amounts of toxins, such as benzene and toluene, into the ground that then jeopardize the quality of our drinking water," Hinchey of New York said.
The fact that they are being pumped some 8-10,000 ft down, and are then removed, accounted for and safely disposed of in other wells at depths well below the few hundred feet to the water table is irrelevant to a point of view that seems to want the practice of hydrofracing completely banned. It might be interesting to hear where he expects the heating fuel to come from for his constituents next winter.

Certainly they should not, it seems, expect much help from Alaska, the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee has refused permission to use directional drilling to reach oil formations in the Arctic Natural Wildlife Refuge, in a way that would not put drilling rigs into the refuge.

As another part of that action the Committee voted to end the ban on drilling offshore in the Eastern Gulf, something not that popular in Florida. But it will require a state initiative to remove the ban that Florida has imposed.

Offshore Sweden and Finland plans are still moving forward to run the Nord Stream gas pipeline down through the Baltic. But there is a rumor that both the Swedish and Finnish authorities may oppose the project.

All in all, perhaps not a good day for the natural gas industry.

Read more!

The Tata Nano and Jevons Paradox

A small snippet of news to underline the comments that I have made about the Tata Nano. In a normal year automobile sales in India run about 1.5 million cars. The Tata Nano went on sale in April, and over the last two months sales have averaged 100,000 cars a month. Because production was only set to be that many this year, many customers are going to have to wait until production gets geared up next year before they can expect delivery. (And just to remind you it is taking Ford up to 6-months to deliver our Fusion Hybrid, so the Indians are not alone in having a long wait).

This is an illustration of Jevons Paradox, in that making cars cheaper and simpler and thus more efficient is resulting in more sales of cars, and thus an overall increase in gasoline demand. Interestingly most of the cars sold are not baseline (the $2.050 version) but also include air conditioning and power windows.

Read more!

Monday, June 8, 2009

Beyond the Storm there will be no calm

Predicting that the next energy crisis is closer than most folk realize is, unfortunately, in some ways the easier part of a look into our future. Because the expectation, fostered by TV movies and our experience from last year, is that should there be another crisis, that it will last only a short time before there is some remedial measure, whether it be a surge in production from Saudi Arabia; withdrawals from the strategic reserve, or some more mythical remedy, somehow, after a short time, the crisis will be resolved.

But the unfortunate reality is that the next time we dance this particular waltz the tune will require a different set of dance steps. Because the solutions that have helped in the recent past to help ameliorate the reduction in traditional supplies of crude have not got the investment, nor have they carried out the development that will allow additional supplies of oil to suddenly spring into being. One of the more obvious examples of this is the increase in supply from the oil sands of Alberta. It was not that long ago that we were looking toward output levels of 3.5 mbd from those deposits, initially by 2015. But just today Standard and Poor’s has lowered the credit rating for companies working in those fields.
“The downturn in oil prices that began in the second half of 2008 brought to the forefront the rapid increase in operating costs that oil-sands producers reported,” Standard & Poor’s said. “At the time we originally rated oil-sands producers, we expected operating costs to be in the teens. We have seen operating costs rise to more than C$30 ($26.75) per barrel on average and rise above C$40 a barrel for some producers in 2008.”

The investments that would be required to bring the production to 3.5 mbd in 2020, the more recent target are not being made. Syncrude has been cutting production, Suncor is merging with PetroCanada as a better place to invest, rather than just in the oil sands. It is this lack of investment, or the curtailment or delay in moving previous investments forward that are now of concern. As the IEA has just noted
Over the last six months many planned large scale upstream oil and gas projects involving around 2 million barrels per day of oil production capacity and 1 billion cubic feet per day of gas supply were cancelled indefinitely, the IEA’s executive director Nobuo Tanaka today told the Asia Oil and Gas Conference in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

A further 35 projects involving 4.2 million barrels per day of oil capacity and 2.3 billion cubic feet per day of gas capacity were delayed by at least 18 months.
His comments were matched by those from the Chief Executive of Shell:
Despite the current economic crisis, he said demand was projected to double by 2050 as the world population grows from 6 billion to 9 billion by that time. He said oil corporations should invest now in technology and develop new sources to reap benefits when the recovery comes.

"The oil and gas industry cannot supply all this additional demand ... this means the next price spike is in the making," he told more than 1,000 delegates at a two-day oil and gas conference here.
Some of the delays have been identified:
Though information is not always available, there has been in 2009 major projects deferment or cancellation in our region such as the Al Zour (615 thousand bpd), Al Shaheen (250 thousand bpd) and Al Jubail (400 thousand bpd) refineries in Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia respectively and the development of the Manifa (900 thousand bpd) oil field in Saudi Arabia which is said to be deferred by at least 18 months.

The Karan gas field in Saudi Arabia also is said to be delayed for a short while to allow a contract renegotiation.
A similar lack of investment in Russia (which is running at about 9.8 mbd of production significantly above the 8.35 mbd production from Saudi Arabia) is also raising concern
"Unless we invest large sums in the development of new fields in East Siberia, Yamal and the Arctic, in a certain period we will see the prime cost of oil production in Russia hike, which could affect the situation on the global market," Viktor Vekselberg said during discussions on oil prices at the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum.

These investments are not being made, and the time for them to have impact is passing. Thus as we begin to see the crisis develop over the next twelve months, one can also anticipate that the available production will not increase, but rather slide further, so that any growth in the world economy and end to the recession will likely be severely threatened by the increasing price of fuel.

Further, at that point, we may reach a situation where supply begins to fall, despite the higher prices, because of an inability to provide the greater volumes. At which time the lack of willingness to address this crisis will be brought home in a hurry, to those who currently ignore it.

Read more!

Sunday, June 7, 2009

The Gathering Storm

It seems relatively quiet on the “Peak Oil” front. So much so that there are blogs, such as Peak Oil Debunked that are, you might say, powering down. To a first overview the new Administration is said to “get” the need for renewable energy, and the Stimulus package has had large sums of money set aside to create paths forward through the “valleys of death” which often greet innovative ideas as they move from lab to full-scale implementation.

One might think, therefore, that we had weathered the storm that disturbed the world as oil prices rose to their peak, just under a year ago, and that energy supplies are now adequate and prices may be stable, while the world moves on to attend to other aspects of its business. With the coming meeting in Copenhagen on Climate Change this December and the moves within Congress to get the Waxman-Markey bill on Energy and Climate acceptable to enough players to get it approved now in full swing, Climate Change seems to have moved back into the driving seat and Energy Independence and concerns over supply are diminished.

Sadly, however, the events that underlay the drive up in oil prices, and the resulting impact on the global economy, did not go away, but were only transiently made ineffectual. The facts that markets are tightening is shown, both by the price increase in crude, now back up to $70, and the increasing sale of oil that has been, until now, stored in tankers. The current rise in prices already has Goldman Sachs predicting oil prices over $85 by the end of the year. They note the IEA conclusion that the drop in oil demand is about over, with an average level of demand for the year expected to be 83.2 mbd. This presages what they are increasingly concerned about, that is an “unrecognized energy crisis.”

It is now recognized by a number of agencies and forecasters that non-OPEC oil production has peaked, and Goldman anticipates the impact that this will have:
The bank says global supply growth over the next five years will dwindle to just 650,000 barrels a day—due to lagging investment and output in non-OPEC countries, especially. Goldman expects non-OPEC supply, about 60% of the world market, to fall by 400,000 barrels a day this year and by 910,000 barrels a day in 2010.
This puts control of oil supply, and therefore price, firmly into the hands of OPEC. Whether the individual members thereof can control themselves sufficiently to maintain the tight demand:supply balance that gives absolute control to price is unlikely. For example, despite the supposed limit, OPEC increased production in May.
Oil output averaged 28.15 million barrels a day last month, up 405,000 from April, according to the survey of oil companies, producers and analysts. The 11 OPEC members with quotas, all except Iraq, pumped 25.76 million barrels a day, 915,000 more than their target.
So production is up, stored oil is being sold, and, while US refinery usage remains down, Chinese refineries are moving into top gear and oil prices continue to rise. And the Tata Nano may come to the US in a couple of years. (My Jevons Paradox comment).

There are two parts to the “hidden” crisis, the first holds while OPEC retains the ability to increase supply to meet demand. Depending on how much oil can be brought into production from existing fields, how much decline in production there is from those existing fields, and how fast new fields can be brought on line, all control how far OPEC can go to meet increasing demand as the world economy and demand starts to inch back. Goldman believes that this will only hold true for another year.
2010H2: A likely return to energy shortages as dwindling OPEC spare capacity is likely unable to meet rising demand as Non-OPEC production growth is restricted by limited investment in oil production infrastructure. We are introducing an end 2010 WTI price forecast of $95/bbl.

In other words about a year from now the world will again see the intersection of available supply and demand – with consequent increase in prices. Goldman think that this will cause an increase in oil price to $95/bbl. I think they’re kidding themselves.

Of course they are likely more realistic that the Department of Energy. The latest TWIP has the following projection for prices over the next 20 years. It is already out of date. (I must get back to that in a future post, since having not looked for a couple of weeks, I see that summer demand is finally beginning to appear.)

But this is not the only energy source over which we should be concerned. While, as I noted the other day, natural gas might be able to meet half the gas demand in a decade from the gas shales, the question in the short term is where are we going to get the fuel this time next year. The continuing decline in drilling rig usage in the US, has the numbers down to about half the number active last year, and the short operational life of the highly-productive gas shale wells means that they must be replaced within two years. At present that is not happening. Thus we will see a coming shortage of natural gas, perhaps also by the second half of next year.

Which leaves me with coal, and I just happened to note that in the latest version of former-Vice President Gore’s slides that he has a couple where he happily notes the large number of coal-fired power stations that have had their plans cancelled.
The coal-fired power plant that was cancelled in Michigan on May 1st is the 97th to be rejected since 2001, and the ninth this year. The number of planned coal plants across America has plummeted from 150 to 60 in the past five years. Last year 5,465 megawatts (MW) of new electricity were announced, but more than twice that capacity—12,572mw, according to Edison Electric Institute, which represents the electricity industry—was subtracted because of cancellations or delays. The nine coal plants cancelled this year alone, Edison notes ruefully, would have provided about 6,650mw of power, or enough to heat almost 5m homes.

Now this may lead to an interesting Conundrum. Those who believe that current global temperatures are driven by greenhouse gases, such as those at Climate Progress, really need it to get hotter to validate their models, and thus have cast their hopes of a change from the current cooling on an upcoming El Nino. However, should this arrive, and give us a scorching summer next year, then we may not have the power available to meet demand, given the unfolding situations defined above. Which would make it difficult for the Administration (and other like-minded governments) that have themselves, or their supporters, go to the polls in the Fall of 2010.

And if that switch from cooling to warming doesn’t happen, then with another year of disparity with the AGW models, it will be more difficult to defend the current position, and lack of investment in short-term supplies rather than the longer-term initiatives that DOE is currently putting into place. So again the poll results may not be gratifying.

The storm is thus gathering, and while it may not hit at full force for a year yet, I am afraid no-one yet knows if there are even lifeboats on board, let alone where they are and how we should use them.



Read more!

Saturday, June 6, 2009

Some thoughts on statistics

Back when both my arms were fully functional (a time that hopefully will return soon) I would spend one of the two posts I wrote on Saturdays looking at what was being said on some of the Climate debate websites. I visit sites on both sides of the debate, being particularly interested in the evidence that is called forth, and the conclusions drawn from it. (The current list is given by the CC sites on the blogroll). These usually lead on to others, and so one can, to a degree, filter out new evidence from that which is being rehashed. However it can require a bit more due diligence, when both sides claim that the rational answer lies only with their side of the argument.

Consider, for example, the little debate this week between Real Climate and Climate Audit on the analysis of the data from the Antarctic that I have mentioned in an earlier couple of posts. The debate relates to how many Principal Components (PCs)* should be considered in deriving the predictive equation from which to generate the model results that decide whether the Antarctic is warming or cooling.

In the original paper Steig et al had used 3 PCs in order to generate the model and thus to conclude:
Here we show that significant warming extends well beyond the Antarctic Peninsula to cover most of West Antarctica, an area of warming much larger than previously reported. West Antarctic warming exceeds 0.1 °C per decade over the past 50 years, and is strongest in winter and spring. Although this is partly offset by autumn cooling in East Antarctica, the continent-wide average near-surface temperature trend is positive.
The paper had a number of flaws in it, based on the source data, but I initially assumed that the statistical analysis was carried out using reasonably widely accepted methods, a conclusion that I am increasingly unsure of.

In an earlier post at Climate Audit the number of PCs used was shown to have a very dramatic effect on the conclusions that could be drawn from the data with Antarctica getting either warmer or cooler depending on how many PCs were chosen (ranging up to 15). And so it seems that it is time to “bite the bullet” and talk a little about what proxies, PC’s and the terms that crop in these discussions mean. (And then to point to the misdirection of a couple of stories where they aren't).


I originally sought wisdom from review of the debate over the use of recognized statistical methods that was performed for the House Energy and Commerce Committee.
The Chairman of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce along with Chairman of the Subcommittee of Oversight and Investigations have been interested in discovering whether or not the criticisms of Mann et al. are valid and if so, what are the implications. To this end, Committee staff asked for advice as to the validity of the complaints of McIntyre and McKitrick [MM] and related implications. Dr. Wegman formed an ad hoc Committee (Drs. Edward J. Wegman – George Mason University, David W. Scott – Rice University, and Yasmin H. Said – The Johns Hopkins University). The Committee was organized with our own initiative as a pro bono committee.
It submitted a report to the Committee on Energy and Commerce.

As part of that report they explained PC analysis thus:
*Principal component analysis is a method often used for reducing multidimensional datasets to lower dimensions for analysis. In this context, dimensions refer to the number of distinct variables. The time series proxy data involved are transformed into their principal components, where the first principal component is intended to explain most of the variation present in the variables. Each subsequent principal component explains less and less of the variation. In the methodology of MBH98/99, the first principal component is used in the temperature reconstruction, and also has the highest explained variance. This method is intended for dimension reduction. In most datasets, the first principal component should be the least smooth (because of the higher variance).
(MBH98/99 refers to the Mann paper that produced the “hockey stick” curve.)

They discuss the effects of temperature change on tree rings, ice cores and coral (of which more anon). but it doesn’t really help those of us who would like this explained in layman’s language. So let me see if I can do that without getting too many folk offended.

When we want to find out the surface temperature of the Earth at some time in the past, and in places where there were neither thermometers, nor folk who kept records, we have to find some other measure that shows what the temperature was. We call these measures “proxies” in part because the behavior of the selected measure approximates the changes in the value we’re interested in. For example, from the list above, the structure, density and width of the ring that a tree grows in a year will vary with the local temperature. And so, by taking a core that recovers the section through a tree that has been around for a long time, we might get an estimate, from the size and structure of the individual tree rings, of the temperature when each ring was formed.

Unfortunately it is not that simple, for example for a Scots pine in Finland.
Earlywood width is controlled by precipitation in June and temperatures in mid winter (December/January) and March. Low mean temperature in April, adequate precipitation in May and a warm July results in wide rings. A long and warm vegetation period results in high latewood density, the strongest correlations occurring with July and August temperature and precipitation.

Tree Ring structure Source NOAA

Since the density and width of the ring can vary from more than one cause, the obvious two cited above are temperature and rainfall, we need to know how much each contributes to the change in the ring. This is not that easy, since the above quote shows that you can’t just use an average value for the year, but have to look at seasonal variables within the year, and this imposes additional variations in the result that we are using as our measure. Further there are some things that may change around the tree that we don’t know about. (from the Wegman report)
Each tree ring is composed of large thin walled cells called early wood and smaller more densely packed thick walled cells called late wood. The average width of a tree ring is a function of many variables including the tree species, tree age, stored carbohydrates in the tree, nutrients in the soil, and climatic factors including sunlight, precipitation, temperature, wind speed, humidity, and even carbon dioxide availability in the atmosphere. Obviously there are many confounding factors so the problem is to extract the temperature signal and to distinguish the temperature signal from the noise caused by the many confounding factors.

Given that complexity the first thing that we need to do is to create a model from data that we already have sufficient information so that we can estimate the impact of changing different values. And this is where our Principal Component comes in. (And for the purists again my apologies I am trying to keep this simple). We can take, for example, data from the last 100 years for a site where we know the variations in temperature, rainfall, relative sunlight etc, and plot the variation in our ring values against these various factors to see which ones best explain the changes in the tree value. The ones that correlate best are called the Principal Components. For example we might find that we explain 60% of the change in tree value by change in temperature, and then when we add rainfall that we have an equation that explains 80% of the variation. By adding further factors (say number of sunny days) we can improve our model so that it predicts with increasing accuracy (smaller variance) the actual values that we found from measuring the rings. So we build our predictive model, adding additional PCs (say soil nutrition) in order of their effectiveness in reducing the variation in the model from the measured data. At some point the improvement is too small to be considered significant, and variables that fall below that value (perhaps insect density) can be neglected.

Having got, or “calibrated” the model, we can then go back from the time and values that we know the PC values for, to look at times when we don’t. Knowing the inter-relationship between the factors and the values, it is possible to estimate what the temperatures were back when the tree rings were grown. (The process is also described by NOAA)

At least that is the basis of the procedure. The problem comes in the complexity of some of the proxies that have been used to assess what the temperatures were back then. To make calculations simpler the data that is used does not use the actual values, but rather looks at the variation in the proxy value from the averaged value over the time period. So that the variation in value from that mean is the measured value against which the models are calibrated. (The process is known as centering the model, since it is the variation from the central value of the data that is used in the subsequent analysis). One of the reasons for doing this is to cope with conditions that are below the average. (By using variation from the mean one can more easily note that a drop in temperature below the average can create a negative growth in the ring that year.) It is important that this be carried out correctly since, when it has not been, and the Wegman report notes that the “hockey stick” paper did not do so, then the results obtained can be flawed.
Our committee believes that the assessments that the decade of the 1990s was the hottest decade in a millennium and that 1998 was the hottest year in a millennium cannot be supported by the MBH98/99 analysis. As mentioned earlier in our background section, tree ring proxies are typically calibrated to remove low frequency variations. The cycle of Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age that was widely recognized in 1990 has disappeared from the MBH98/99 analyses, thus making possible the hottest decade/hottest year claim. However, the methodology of MBH98/99 suppresses this low frequency information. The paucity of data in the more remote past makes the hottest-in-a-millennium claims essentially unverifiable.

It also comments on something else that I find quite troubling, namely the very small circle that is formed of the “climate scientists” that publish in this area, and their inter-relationships, with most of the major authors in the field being tied to Dr. Mann – but that is an issue for another day. However, this "clique" does not include many with a strong grounding in statistics, and it is this weakness, and the errors generated in the predictions as a result, which make the papers that the groups generate (and which get significant international publicity) very vulnerable to criticism, which may well be justified.

I want to go back, however, to the comments on coral, since the growth of coral is one of the parameters that are used to assess Climate Change. The Wegman Report noted:
Reef-building corals are strongly affected by temperature and, as temperature drops, the rate of calcification drops with lower temperature potentially presaging the death of the colony. Coral growth rates vary over a year and can be sectioned and x-rayed to reveal high- and low-density bands. High density layers are produced during times of higher sea surface temperatures. Thus not unlike tree rings, data on corals also can be calibrated to estimate (sea) surface temperatures.

I draw attention to that since there is a current interest in coral data, with stories commenting on the “ravages” that will occur to coral with increasing temperature. And yet, even in those stories, dealing with coral damage one finds
Sea level rise, which is projected to occur this century as the world's glaciers melt, would not necessarily kill coral reefs, Tamelander said, since the reefs can grow as waters get higher.

"A healthy reef should be able to keep up," Tamelander said.
. Climate Audit points out the inadequate statistical analysis behind the headline, and then when the statistics are applied the conclusion is wrong.

But then these facts, and the impact of land sinking
"It doesn't matter who's causing global warming. Sea-level rise is something we can measure," said Rob Young, a geosciences professor at Western Carolina University. "You can't argue that sea level isn't rising."

And it has been rising faster in the mid-Atlantic because the land here is sinking. Understanding this phenomenon requires thinking of the Earth as an enormous balloon. Push down in one spot on the ball's surface and surrounding areas are raised up. Glaciers did this to Earth's surface during the last ice age: They pressed down on northern North America and areas to the south tilted up, like the other end of a seesaw. Today, thousands of years after the glaciers retreated, the seesaw is tipping back the other way, and the region from New York to North Carolina is falling about six inches per century.

And this is my gripe for the day – we see anecdotal headlines about how this disaster or that is coming, courtesy of global warming, but these warnings are rarely accompanied by an adequate statistical analysis that shows that the facts discussed are in fact real and correlated to global warming in the manner projected.

One can see this, for example, in the recent comment by Kofi Annan story on the level of death caused by global warming. This is rebutted by the statistics as noted in the Wall Street Journal (Hat tip Irv.) There is no mention of the hundreds of thousands of acres of the sub-Sahara that have been converted to agriculture in the last decade, thereby prolonging, instead of shortening life. Rather those stories are hidden in the headlines of starvation
Oxfam expects cereal production across five countries in the dry Sahel belt south of the Sahara -- Burkina Faso, Mali, Mauritania, Niger and Senegal -- will be a record 18.5 million tonnes this year, but the food on sale will be beyond the budget of many in these, some of the world's poorest countries.


Read more!

Thursday, June 4, 2009

House Hearing on Hydrofracturing

This morning the House Committee on Natural Resources Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources held a Hearing, motivated by (among others) Congresswoman Diana DeGette of Denver, to remove the Safe Drinking Water Act exemption from the hydraulic fluids used in hydraulically fracturing (hydrofracing) oil and gas wells. The exemption was granted in 2005. It is particularly relevant to today and tomorrow’s supplies of energy since it is only through the extensive use of hydrofracing that it is possible to viably recover the large quantities of natural gas that are now being developed from the gas shale deposits around the country.

I was led to listen in by Joe Romm at Climate Progress who seems to have just discovered both Peak Oil and the Gas Shales, and I am glad that I did. The issue seems to have become of increasing public interest since the discovery that one of the larger gas shale deposits in the country is the Marcellus, which can be found under parts of New York and Pennsylvania, and with the large volumes of fluid that are used in the hydrofracing process (of which more in a bit) there is a growing concern (and some rumors generated) that the fluids from that process will get into the local drinking water and surface waters; that the fluids contain toxic materials, and thus the public is being put, unnecessarily, at risk.


The witnesses before the Sub-Committee were:

Mr. Douglas Duncan who is 
Associate Coordinator for the Energy Resources Program of the United States Geological Survey.

Mr. Scott Kell
, President
 of the Ground Water Protection Council and a State Regulatory , Official from Ohio.

Mr. Mike John who is the 
Vice President of Corporate Development and Government Relations, for the Eastern Division
 of Chesapeake Energy Corporation.

Mr. Lynn Helms who is the 
Director of the Oil and Gas Division of the 
North Dakota Industrial Commission, and who spoke of the activity of the Interstate Oil and Gas Compact Commission.

Mr. Albert F. Appleton who is a consultant on 
Infrastructure and the Environment and a 
former Director of the New York City Water and Sewer System.

Of these, Mr. Duncan spoke of the size of the gas shale resource, on land in the United States (and did mention that the USGS was working out how much there was in the rest of the world) but otherwise seemed to try and stay outside of the debate. Interestingly, later in the debate, ho noted that the USGS had data for the public lands in the United States, but had not finished the survey as to what lay beneath private lands.

In his opening statement Scott Kell spoke to the work that the States already do in this regard. He specifically cited two reports, though I only got the reference to the first. That was “Modern Shale Gas Development in the United States – A Primer”, (pdf) and it appears to be an excellent reference to the topic, and I am going to use it to substantiate some of the comments from the panel of witnesses.

He noted that the rumors of ill health caused by hydrofrac fluids suggested up to 1,000 cases of environmental damage focused on six states. He contacted the relevant agencies in those states and found that the reports were unfounded. The Ground Water Protection Council was founded by State Oil and Gas Regulators and is designed to protect the public’s water.

Mike John, speaking on behalf of Cheasapeake, noted that the Marcellus is likely to be a real game changer in regard to US reserves. It will provide an “ocean of natural gas,” with production being limited by demand, since there is now too much supply. They have 94 rigs operating and he described defining the shale in their lease, identifying the sweet spots with 3-D seismic and then drilling, from a single 5-acre site, perhaps 6 t0 10 wells that go down 8 – 10,000 ft (depending on the deposit) and then turn lateral and go out a mile horizontally. He believes that the four major gas shales (Haynesville, Fayetteville, Marcellus and Woodford) will generate half the US demand for natural gas by 2020, at 30 bcf/day.

Lynn Helms spoke of the benefits to come from the Bakken in North Dakota, as a State Official he has no greater priority than protecting the water, but has seen no credible real threat to the water and believes that the industry is adequately regulated.

Thus the first four speakers (or at least the middle three) were of the “it ain’t broke so why fix it,” school, and it was left to the last member of the panel, Albert Appleton, to explain the concerns that had led to the Hearing and possible change in legislation). He has been, as one concerned with the NY water supply, a critical evaluator of what goes on in the watershed that feeds water to the city and the state. He spoke to the fact that we are supposed to be moving away from fossil fuels toward renewable ones, that there are concerns with the fluids that are used in hydrofracing, and the industry that says it can’t afford more regulation is the one that makes these huge profits. His main concern was that the fluids used are toxic and do not biodegrade, so that even though they are stored in deep wells, they are still there as a threat. But there are also concerns that there are not enough regulators to ensure compliance with the regulations, and that water withdrawal may have severe and negative impact on communities. And he returned to the point that the Government is now pouring billions into green energy but this will compete with natural gas, so that if we subsidize the gas by easing the regulations we are undercutting the green energy program. And we have to be concerned about global warming. (Joe Romm is quoting NASA as saying that we will set a new global temperature record within a year or two).

Well after these opening statements, the Sub-Committee members had their say, some speaking more themselves, and one or two merely asking questions. The ad hominem argument that appears in other discussions also popped up here. Congressman Hinchey (I believe) from New York asked Mr Kell where he got his funding and focused in on the oil and gas companies that therefore “bought” the conclusions he had provided. (This was rebutted by the witness). He was particularly concerned with the benzine in the fluid, and returned to its toxic nature and longevity once spilled.

Congressman Boren from McAlester, OK talked about the rigs that are laid down, and the high unemployment in the oil and gas business in his district, for him $4 gas was too cheap. He did note that then Senator Obama voted to provide the exemption, and he wondered why they were trying to “solve a problem that doesn’t exist.” He got the witnesses to differentiate between the depth of the wells (8-10,000 ft) where the fluid is used, and the 2-300 ft of the water supplies of concern. They also pointed out that without the hydrofrac, gas from the shales can’t happen. He noted that the prevailing backup to the wind and solar farms being installed today is natural gas, and so we really need it.

Congresswoman Lummis from Wyoming talked of the “game change” nature of the natural gas, and asked of the consequences of the proposed change. The example given in response was the effect of the LEAF (Legal Environmental Assistance Foundation) legislature in Alabama which was directed at control of coal bed methane and hydrofracing (historic review.) The result of the judgement was to place a two-year drilling moratorium in the state. She urged the Sub-Committee not to remove the exemption.

The State regulators pointed out that the States had been handling this problem for years, without documented cases where there were problems in over 20 years of operation.

Congressman Gohmert of Texas pointed out that they are drilling into the Barnett shale in downtown Ft Worth without problems. Congressman Fleming of Louisiana commented on the developments in the Haynesville shale and how they were a great boost for the local economy, without incidents.

Yet in a reply Mr Appleton returned to the point that non-Federal regulation of the industry was a subsidy to the National Gas Industry.

Congressman Sarbanes of Maryland went back to the toxic chemical point, seeking to determine if any of the fluids were Class 1 chemicals (they are Class 2) He was answered that all sites (to comply with OSHA) must have the pertinent MSDS data sheets for all the chemicals at the site and available – so the fluid chemistry is determinable. However, it was pointed out that the chemistry changes from well to well and site to site, and thus it is impossible to generate a single “one mix fits all.” The fluids from the well are stored on site, in either tanks or double clay-lined pits, from which the fluid (monitored by the agencies on a per barrel basis) is transported to injection wells and pumped deep underground. There are some issues with water quantity however, (though this was not followed up on very much).

In terms of price, Mr John said that Chesapeake could live with $4 gas (per thousand cu ft) but that he expected the price to return to $6 to $8 fairly soon. They have not shut in any of their wells in the Marcellus. In response to the question as to what a typical fracing fluid contains as a chemical package he began to read the table (exhibit 36) below.

Typical fracing fluid contents

Congresswoman DeGette then came into the Hearing and asked questions as to the objection to the legislation. If the chemicals are reported anyway, why is there a problem. Some foks say there are no incidents, but incidents don’t always get reported. And there are stories of contamination, and injuries.

There had been one break in the Hearing and I was distracted a couple of times so that this is not a full and complete report, just what I was able to note.

My sense was that most of the Sub-committee did not see the reason for change, with only two or three members pushing the need for a change in regulation, but I suspect that not all the members were there and that this may have more passion on the part of those seeking the change.

Read more!

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

On burning wood, coppicing and pollarding

The power plant on our campus is set up so that it can burn either coal, natural gas or wood feed stocks. At the present time the natural gas lines are blocked, since the trends of increasing price made it uneconomic to use within the boilers. However the plant uses around wood for 40% of the feed, and has for a number of years. It helps, both with pollution control, and with the overall plant economics (oftimes being cheaper per kwh generated). We are located adjacent to a national forest and thus there is a ready supply of material.

This practice is beginning to catch on, as Bloomberg notes:
Using biomass for power and heat -- mainly from poplar, willow and pine trees -- grew by 25 percent during the past two decades, according to the International Energy Agency, the Paris-based adviser to 28 oil-consuming nations such as the U.S.
Industrialized nations got 4 percent of their energy from biomass in 2006, the most recent data available from the IEA. That was the equivalent of 151 million tons of oil.

Chips of wood stumps and branches, heated to 400 degrees Celsius (750 degrees Fahrenheit) at the Novus furnace, are as efficient as coal and cheaper: European Union rules don’t require carbon-dioxide permits because the trees absorbed a like amount of the gas before harvest, making them carbon-neutral.
Now in relatively small quantities this is a viable program, and for domestic heating wood has long been a fall-back supply (we buy several cords each winter to burn in our tile stove).

It is particularly useful as a supply in those parts of the country where solar and wind energies are not going to be locally available as viable resources (long-term, long-distance transmission of generated power is an issue I’ll duck today).

However, before everyone rushes out to get a stove, furnace, or even a fireplace it is worth reminding folks of some historic facts (some of which Bloomberg also catches).
Generally you burn up a tree a whole lot faster than you can grow a new one. Out of that reality grew the European practice of coppicing where the young limbs of the tree are harvested back to just above the stump, and the stump thenn allowed to regrow limbs. (The practice dates back to before Henry VIII). Trees such as birch may, for example, be harvested every three or four years, while the basic root of the tree may survive for centuries..

Coppiced trees. (Source Hampshire County Council)

The alternative practice is known as pollarding where the tree is first allowed to grow to some height, and then the limbs are cut back. Because the growth then occurs at a later stage in the tree life, the trees will mature in a way that coppiced trees won’t though the production can come faster. It is used where livestock could come in and eat the coppiced limbs (Henry VIII passed laws about fencing the coppiced plantations, thereby enclosing parts of the forest). Both practices were common in Europe with their need for fuel and fencing material, oak and willow being commonly harvested this way, and the characteristic tree shapes are a feature of landscape portraits by artists such as Gainsborough , Knight and Price. It is a practice that, though laudatory for many reasons, has fallen into abeyance, since it is, among other things, very labor intensive. It is suggested that less than 3% of modern woodland is coppiced. There are some attempts to regenerate the industry.

Pollarded Trees (source Wikipedia

Short of these land management and wood harvesting techniques, wood can only be expected to supply a limited amount of fuel before it too runs out. Pelletizing the waste products from wood manufacture has created an industry that can, again, supply a limited market with fuel. Until recently the price has been relatively stable in comparison with other fuels.

Relative wood pellet cost (source New England Wood Pellet LLC)

An average household is anticipated to use some 2.67 tons of pellets a heating season, and they have advantages of being cleaner and simpler to operate than the wood that heats me at least three times (stacking, moving and burning).

Were the whole nation to turn to wood, however, then as happened in Europe in previous times, the cost of the fuel could well skyrocket. I have mentioned in earlier posts that King Edward I (Longshanks) tried to ban the burning of coal back around 1306, but the costs for wood were so much higher, that the ban was ineffectual, as were subsequent bans by monarchs such as Elizabeth 1. And even today one finds that there are those who would rather burn coal than wood. The stove that we have can be adapted (using two grates in about 2 minutes) to burn coal, however, as yet we have not examined that option.

The Bloomberg article notes that one supplier of pellets has already sold this years supply, and with 800,000 households (I suspect many, like us in more rural parts of the country) already using wood, overall supplies may also become tighter. And, in Europe RWE is building wood-fired power plants, and eighteen months ago a large-scale plant opened on Teeside in the UK.

This 30 MWe plant uses 300.000 tons of woodchips a year.
The wood for the station comes from four separate sources. Around 40% of the 300,000t a year total is recycled wood from UK Wood Recycling. This is received, stored and chipped on a nearby, separately owned site at Wilton. A further 20% comes to the site already chipped as offcuts from sawmills. SembCorp is working with the Forestry Commission to bring another 20% from north east forests in the form of small roundwood logs – items sometimes left on the forest floor after routine tree felling operations.

Finally, 20% comprises specially grown energy crops in the form of short rotation coppice willow. The company Greenergy is supplying the wood, to be grown by farmers and other landowners within a 50-mile radius of the site.

The new plant required the growth of around 7,500 acres of coppice in the area, an activity that is creating local wildlife havens.

As an example of the benefits available to local farmers is the case of the Corrigans near Middlesborough and the power plant. They have three 25 acre willow plantations, the first of which has just come to first harvest. Once dried it will be shipped to Wilton and bring in around $20,000. As the plants mature this harvest is expected to increase. There are other advantages
He said: "There has been a dramatic increase in insect and bird life especially snipe, woodcock, lapwings and reed bunting as well as pipistrelle and long eared bats and three species of owl.

So we have found a couple more words that you should probably add to your energy lexicon. And they provide not only fuel, but also jobs.









Read more!