Friday, April 17, 2009

Sun Power from Space, an old idea returns

There is a new company called Solaren, that has just signed an agreement with the California-based utility Pacific Gas and Electric in which the utility will buy 200 MW of power that will come from solar panels located in space.

And this is mildly frustrating, because somewhere in the files of my last 40-years, there is a whole set of reports from NASA reporting on, and looking into the economics of doing this very thing. Now that was back about 30-years ago, and at the time I remember writing a fairly long report explaining why it would not work. Part of it was based on the overall economic figures that NASA had used, and part more specifically on the relative cost of the panels to make significant power levels. (At the time they were to be made of gallium arsenide, and the entire arsenic production of the United States was less than 25 tons if my memory serves, and I made some disparaging remarks about those who might like to have an arsenic mine next door).

Well move ahead those 30 years and things have changed a bit. Not only do we now have solar panels in space, delivering power to the space station, but they can be made smaller, lighter and of other materials.

At the time of the NASA work, the intent was to send the energy back to Earth in the form of microwaves, with large areas being cordoned off to receive the energy (since it would likely cook anyone or any animal or bird that entered the receiving zone). That particular form of transmission also raised some ribald remarks, and the odd cartoon as I recall, and the current method proposed is to convert it into radio frequency energy for transmission.


Because the satellites can be mounted out in space beyond the Earth’s shadow they can receive energy from the sun all the time, and thus not be affected by either clouds or the day/night shift, so that they could provide baseload power to the utility (as is the intent). This will require that the panels be some 22,000 miles from the Earth - a range now achievable by rocket.

A second company, called Space Energy, is also advancing the idea. NASA checked out the transmission idea back in 2008, but what is not part of the story is that apparently the test was a failure, not a success
Unfortunately for Space Energy, Inc and the entire concept of space based solar power, the actual test results conducted for a Discovery channel documentary proved a total failure. The former NASA executive and physicist who organized the experiment, John Mankins, admitted in a press conference that the $1 Million budget spent of the experiment resulted in less than 1/1000th of 1% of the power transmitted being received on the other island.

The most successful test of wireless power transmission over any distance at high efficiency was conducted by Bill Brown in 1975. Using a NASA deep space tracking dish they transmitted 30kw over 1.6 km (1 mile) at 82.5% efficiency at the Goldstone Deep Space Communication Complex. A Since Geostationary orbit is 36,000 km (22,500 miles) away from earth the space based power station needs to efficiently transmit power over twenty thousand times further than has ever been achieved to date.

Apparently the idea was one of the early ideas submitted to the “Change.Gov” website, where it can be commented on by the public. However, having just dropped by to find the reference I see that after 699 comments, the site has been closed for further comment.

Given that the plan is now to for the utility to get approval from state regulators it should be interesting to see how this project unfolds over the summer. There is some talk of seeing the first return of power in the 2016 time frame. The ground receiving station being located somewhere in Fresno County.

In the meanwhile I am going to go and start digging through some of those old boxes in the back of the office. There is a video of the possible project here (you might note the size of the field array on Earth to receive the signal.)

Read more!

Thursday, April 16, 2009

The Post and the Secretary - a comment on a discussion

One of the major planned bastions of the Obama Administration is intended to center about a change in the Energy Policy of the country. Given that the folk that are now in charge of a number of issues come from California Congressman Waxman (the 30th District which includes Beverley Hills and Malibu); Senator Boxer from California, and Secretary Chu of the Department of Energy; there is a predilection to call the new policy California-based, rather than the Texas-based orientation of the Bush Administration. And the experiences of the key players will likely color the thinking and planning that will take policy forward. (Recognizing as was noted in the EIA meeting last week, that given the need to get 60 votes out of the Senate, that such a process will dictate adopted policy). So it is interesting, with that filter in mind, to listen to the interview that Secretary Chu gave to the Washington Post today.

The interview begins (the Post listing is not in order, so this was the top bit) with a question on getting folk to use public transport, and conservation as a necessary early step in reducing the national energy demand. The question illustrates the difficulty between setting an overall goal, and the problems in trying to implement those goals in a time of financial exigency. Consider that while, in order to save money in tougher times folk recognize that they are better off taking public transport. The problem is that as that demand goes up, from Washington D.C to Florida, and all across the country, it bumps into the harsh reality that cuts in municipal income are forcing the services to become more restricted. As someone noted “it makes no sense to hire a construction worker, and fire a bus driver.” Unfortunately that part of the question was not fully addressed by the Secretary, though he did note that 60-70% of transportation fuel is used in the private sector, but then focused on the more fundamental theme, that he has expounded upon before, about conservation of energy. In this case he would replace the construction worker with someone that can weatherize your home. (Though still not helping the bus driver). But even here I think he has difficulty. Because to sell this message (that weatherizing your home can pay for itself in a year or eighteen months), requires that he get people to hire folk to work on their homes.


The difficulty with this when times are tougher, is that it is requiring individual members of the public to become involved and actually spend their own money in the process. (We had some small remodeling done over the winter, and according to the folks we hired, there is very little work out there at the moment). In tough times that is going to be a hard sell, high return or not. And while the sale that the Secretary talks about hinges on folk seeing the payback in lower energy bills after the investment, or getting a bank loan to make the improvements, which is a group that also needs to be persuaded.

In regard to the use of solar energy, and particularly photo-voltaics, the Secretary plays around with words. At the moment solar is much more expensive than conventional other fuels. But he notes that if you look instead at the energy supply for peak power then, instead of costing $0.10 per kwh, that currently costs $0.40 per kwh. So that instead of replacing other power sources if one instead makes the comparison with solar (at say $0.23 per kWh) then solar becomes a logical choice. The problem with that argument is that I suspect that solar is only considered as being at $0.23 if the investment can be paid off by continuous supply of power into the grid at the time that the sun is shining, in which case it is displacing existing, lower cost systems. If it is installed and then only run in times of high demand, then ROI would surely drive the costs over $0.23 and it would still not be economical.

Turning to oil dependence he tried to distinguish between folks reducing their driving habits purely because the price went up, over their decision to do so because of the dependence on foreign oil. He recognized that countries are now jockeying for guaranteed access to the increasingly limited supply, and this dependency is a “very scary proposition” particularly if it starts to define our geopolitical stance. He did suggest that people conserve in personal travel by driving more fuel efficient cars and car pooling, but when challenged as to whether folks would, he merely hoped so. And then he spoke up for the use of bio-waste as well as specifically grown crops to generate bio-energy.

In looking at the benchmark of 100-day accomplishments he is proud of getting the loan guarantee program to actually start making loans, whereas when he came in the likely start date had been projected as sometime next year.

For climate change, and carbon reduction he still holds to the target of reducing carbon emissions by 80% by 2050. He still sees energy conservation, in things like buildings, as the lowest hanging fruit. He thinks we can reduce building energy costs by 80%, with today’s technologies and without solar panels. He feels that the Department can design tools that will help people do this., and that the added investments to make them efficient will then pay for themselves in 10-years or less.

But as with cars, and the change to higher mileage vehicles with improved batteries, there is no recognition that this problem needs an immediate solution. Rather the Department is going to continue developing battery technology, with the hope that in time the cost differential for a hybrid will be small enough that it will become more attractive to the public. As it will continue to work on the design tools for buildings, but there is no sense of emergency in the talk, no sense that the time where we will need to have answers is in the relatively immediate future. Interestingly when he was selling the concepts of hybrids he argued that they were only $5,000 more expensive than conventional models, and yet when arguing the need for research on batteries he put the price of current batteries in hydrids as being on the order of $10,000. (Tsk!) But new batteries are at least 5 years away.

I must confess that I do find it a little odd that he would have us concerned over climate change, with a potential for that impact being towards the back end of this century, with much less concern over the more imminent arrival of fossil fuel shortages, which may well occur within the period of the current Administration.

And in that regard he talked of the differences between regulatory and legislative paths towards reducing carbon emissions. He anticipates that the EPA will move on the regulatory process, which may, in turn stimulate more legislative activity. And looking further into coal, the rate of advance of “clean”coal’ is going to depend on the costs and the technologies that show that they can work. These are pilot demonstration plans going forward that will initially be expensive, but will come down with use. And he thinks that as a result clean coal could happen. He thinks that the economic and social consequences of continuing to burn coal are becoming more evident and more pressing. (One wonders what he is thinking of in particular) But again this is quite generalized, and not focusing on the shorter term path forward, and, as I keep listening to the Secretary the more I worry that he does not see the time scale over which changes need to be made.
.

Read more!

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

TWIP in mid-April

After the excitement of the two days in Washington last week at the EIA Energy Conference, we are now returned to casting our eyes over the entrails of The EIA’s This Week in Petroleum. Interestingly this week thy are playing the same sort of forecasting game that I have been trying to achieve with the looks at how gasoline sales are developing, as they relate to vehicle miles driven and whether, looking at historical trends, we can expect demand to start to rise.

The EIA view is that, all things considered, they anticipate a 1% increase in demand for gasoline this summer. This is significantly less than the usual seasonal trend, but to get to any increase all they had to anticipate that the continued low price for gasoline will be the major driver, against the still declining economy. When we look at the gasoline demand curve, it is remaining remarkably flat (well, OK a tiny rise), and has now dropped below last year’s levels, which were at this point rising quite steadily.

Source TWIP EIA


Driving up through Central Missouri today, the trees were beginning to green up, the redbud was still out, and the sky was blue. A lovely day, which used to be sufficient to justify a pleasant spring drive. Pure pleasure driving is less in fashion these days, except for those with a new vehicle, but as long as prices stay down (and ours are still below $2) I will anticipate that gasoline use may pick up a little more than the EIA predict, stocks have, for example, stopped increasing.

We shall see! On another front today was the last day to file taxes. (And of course we will gloss over some who might have waited until the last minute).

It did get me thinking about the evolving discussion on tax and the fossil fuel industry. It is not that long ago that there was concern over the windfall profits that some of the larger companies were making as oil and gas prices rose. There is now some talk that those days may return soon for those in the palm oil business. However it is happening in Malaysia, and may not last more than two months.

But that again assumes that there is a stability in demand against supply, in the case of palm oil there is a likely increase in production to be anticipated, that may reduce prices. There has been a promise that gasoline taxes (per se) wouldn't be increased in the current Administration. Presumably a lot of road repairs etc can be paid for through the stimulus packages. There remain arguments, however, for an increase in gasoline taxes.

We are going to remain a nation of drivers into the foreseeable future. We will need highways and roads, to get around on, and somewhere those maintenance costs have to be met.

It will be interesting to see, where, down the road, that money is generated.
.

Read more!

Monday, April 13, 2009

On Oil Prices - or a Gentle Cough in Newsweek's direction

Newsweek has a story this week on why we should not be worried about the potential problems of peak oil. (One of the advantages of the Kindle is that I can read this early, one of the disadvantages of this being tax weekend is that I haven’t had time, so hat tip to Gail). Basically it is quoting chapter and verse of the Cornucopian Bible, and sadly it is riddled with misperceptions and the sort of blind faith in “someone who will take care of us” that it does a significant public disservice.

Let me explain the scale of the problem with a couple of examples, as I review parts of the article. To start there is this comment, noting that in real terms the price of oil has not gone up, but rather declined.
This long-term price decline is due mainly to the constant discovery of new fields and greater energy efficiency, making nonsense of the idea that the world is rapidly running out of oil.
To point out the fallacy of assuming this will continue, let me use John Grace’s excellent book on Russian Oil Supply. I use it because it geographically illustrates the point in a way that is more difficult with other countries. First you see the Russians could get all the oil that they needed from around Baku (in what is now Azerbaijan), and then when that proved insufficient, they moved North East and discovered the Volga-Ural Basin. Here, in the 1948 they discovered one of the great oilfields of the World, Romashkino, which held around 17 billion barrels of oil. Romashkino peaked in 1972, and the whole field peaked in 1976, at just under 4.5 mbd, and has been in decline since then. It was here that the technique of water flooding was perfected in Russia.

As Romashkino declined so the Russians moved further east, into Western Siberia, where they found the Samotlor field, Russia’s largest. By 1980 this field was producing 3.4 mbd but it too started to decline and by January 2003 had produced some 16.4 billion barrels and was down to a production of 300,000 bd. So where next? The Russians kept moving East and, at the same time tapped smaller fields, such as Fedorovskoye and Mamontovskoye, which are now running out. They reached Sakhalin Island and that is now in production, but Russian overall production is falling again, so where to move to next? Further East ? Er! Well there is this slight problem – Russia sold “further East”, AKA Alaska, in 1867. And so Alaska has already been put into production, and now is in decline. There are only so many places to look, and as Magellan showed, if you keep moving one way long enough finding new reserves, after a while you get back to where you started from, and you used those already. All the easy oil has now been just about found. The places we are left with to look are more expensive to look, and even more expensive to produce(such as the deep waters of the Gulf, and off Brazil).

There are three parts to the Newsweek argument:
Yet the fact is that the world has faced all these issues before, and for the past 200 years, commodity prices have been trending downwards, thanks to new technologies, greater efficiency in extraction and the substitution of one commodity for another (which explains the high correlation between commodities prices).
In themselves, and at certain levels of production of different items they each have validity, but in the current cycle they significantly ignore the factors of scale and time. Let me explain part of the this with another example. After Hurricane Katrina paid a visit to the Gulf there were a significant number of oil and gas wells that went out of production. Now the oil and gas remaining in those wells is still there, but it is not economic to go back and redrill the formations and restart production for the amount that is left. As the required technologies to generate production become more expensive, so the fields have to produce more to justify that investment.

A case in point here is the development of gas from the shale deposits around the country. With the development of horizontal well drilling, hydrofracing, slick-water hydrofracing, and now multi-stage hydrofracing the wells can produce up to 20 mcf/day. But the wells cost over $5 million and so the gas has to sell for a certain amount to justify that investment, and the fields decline in production at 60% the first year, so that initial number had better be high. At the start of these fields most of the wells are, though as they are finding out in the Haynesville, not all of them. And so where do you look for the next level of technology to find a better way of getting more out? There are some ideas out there (we filed a new patent last month, for example) but these take time to move from lab, to pilot to prototype to full production, and there are not that many ideas in the pipeline because there was, among other things, not that much investment.

We have just about run the gamut of the new technologies for now, and it will take a while to come up with more. Certainly injecting carbon dioxide for enhanced oil recovery can, in the right formations, give you an extra 10% or more, but there are only so many places that that can work, and the expense in getting the gas moved around, compressed etc is significant, and much of that logistic cost, when considered in the past, has been enough to restrict use of the technology.

And so we get to substitution of new fuels. And I guess the Newsweek reporters haven’t been paying attention, because ethanol and biodiesel are the likely candidates at the moment to replace liquid fuels. And neither are at a stage where they can be expanded to produce, for example, the 245,000 bd of oil production that is being lost as Cantarell declines. We are not talking about being able to wait the 10 – 15 years that it is going to take for the work on cellulosic ethanol to generate, economically, the fuel types that we need – these declines are happening, in real time, now!

Both scenarios ignore history, which shows that only one commodity rises in an inflationary environment: gold. Other commodity prices tend to bloom only during the mature stages of a boom when the global economy overheats and demand briefly exceeds supply. At the moment, supply for nearly all commodities far outweighs demand, and likely will decline for at least the next couple of years.
This assumes that there is enough oil, and substitute fuels that will be available, at a reasonable price, as demand resurges. To make that statement with confidence, you need to be able to say where that extra supply is coming from. Russia? It is falling back into decline, as is non-OPEC in general. Within OPEC, as was discussed last week at the EIA meeting, there is only so much additional production available (if in reality it is, and in some cases there are reasonable doubts that it is).

We have seen, in the last few months, as OPEC has cut back production, the matching of demand, in this time of global recession, with supply that is made available. The difference between flat-out production, which we had at times last year, and now, is in the neighborhood of 4 million barrels a day, over a total of about 80 million barrels. Expansion of the markets in China and India does not have to be that great, with a slight return of confidence in the rest of the world, and that cushion will be gone. When there is not enough supply to meet demand at a given price, what happens? Prices go up, and demand drops to meet the new price. But if the commodity is critical, and oil is an integral part of the world we live in, what happens when there is not enough at an acceptable price. What happens when you don't have the fields to open new reserves, when you don't have time to develop the new technology to extract more from existing fields, and when the substitute fuels aren't that ready for prime time?

What actually worries me more than the Newsweek story alone, is the feeling that this reflects the opinions of many in the new Administration, and if they don't realize the scale and imminence of the problems, then by the time that they learn, it will be too late.

And this is one of those predictions that will show results, either their way, or mine, within eighteen months.
.

Read more!

Sunday, April 12, 2009

P61. Pick Points

A few stories of interest to start off the week.

When I wrote about the EIA Energy Conference last week I had promised that I would make a better reference to the views of others who were there. For example, I noted that Reuters had a piece on the final morning session dealing with greenhouse gases and climate change. Robert Rapier has two posts up now, one on Dr Chu’s remarks; and the second on the rest of day 1. Robert went to the session on Transport demand that I missed, and so this is a place to catch up. His take on the Renewable Energy session is also a little different, and so a trip over there would be worthwhile. Gail, at TOD, has so far, only covered the Plenary Session.

Stranded Wind also has a post summarizing the whole Conference at Daily Kos.

Moving on around the world to see what other stories have been gathering headlines, it sometimes seems that one cannot go far without bumping into Gazprom stories. It seems to have troubles on two fronts at the moment. Looking first at its supply, it has (as I noted last Sunday) run into a bit of bother with Turkmenistan. The story got worse as the week continued with a reported gas explosion in a pipeline inside Turkmenistan that was carrying natural gas to Russia. This shut down the feed to Russia.
"Turkmengaz informed Gazprom that on April 9 at 01:32 an explosion occurred at the 487th kilometer of the Davletbat-Daryalik pipeline. Since then, transport of Turkmen gas to Russia has not been carried out," Gazprom said.

"At the present time the Turkmen side is working to rapidly repair the damage.... The damage will not affect the supply of gas to Gazprom's customers," it said in a statement.
This was followed, on Friday, by a story in the LA Times where Turkmenistan blamed Gazprom
Turkmenistan's Foreign Ministry said in a flurry of statements that Russia's Gazprom decided on short notice to reduce the amount of gas it takes from Turkmenistan. Gazprom's export division gave only one day's warning, which wasn't sufficient time for Turkmenistan to reduce its flow into the pipeline network, the ministry said.

The blast, which occurred late Wednesday, "was caused by a gross unilateral violation by Gazpromexport of the norms and rules of the natural gas sales agreement," the statement said. Another statement said Gazprom's actions were "rash and irresponsible" and put lives at risk.
Turkmenistan is now reportedly angry that the Russians are, in contrast, blaming the blast on them. Repairs were scheduled to take 3 days. The story is now being carried in Moscow, where part of the blame is seen to be because of the decision of the Turkmen to seek international bids for a pipeline, instead of giving it to Russia.

There has been a significant drop in demand from Europe. In March Gazprom produced 24% less gas than the same month last year, and is down 18% over the whole quarter. Demand in Russia alone dropped 6.6%. With demand for Russian gas expected to stay depressed by 10% over the next five years. However in the short term, it does report seeing a slight upturn in demand from Europe.

Which brings us to the second side of the story, since Gazprom is now threatening to fine Ukraine for not consuming more gas, and lowering demand below expected levels. With this threat of a lack of customers it seems odd to some that Gazprom is taking the step of buying Eni’s stake in Gazprom Neft (the oil side of the house). At a cost of $4.2 billion it is considered “a strange decision” given the company’s need to cut debt. On the other hand there is now an agreement to ship some of Sakhalin gas to the West Coast of the USA. (Actually to Mexico and then into the US).
In a statement announcing the agreement yesterday, the two companies said liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the newly completed Sakhalin-2 project will be shipped to a regasification facility in Baja California, Mexico. It will then be transported to southern California by pipeline and sold to U. S. consumers by Gazprom's subsidiary in Houston, Gazprom Marketing & Trading USA, Inc.
The first tanker of Sakhalin gas arrived in Japan last Monday, after leaving the island on the 1st April. Japan is expected to take 60% of Sakhalin’s supply (about 7% of Japan’s need) with the remainder being split between South Korea and the USA.

While many eyes on Pakistan are focused on the problems with insurgents and controlling the travel of the Taliban and friends across the border into Afghanistan, it is not as widely known that the country remains in a relatively desperate energy shortage. In one of the latest moves to counter this, the country will go onto daylight saving time on April 15th, in a move that is hoped to save the country 250 MW a day. Given that the country is short around 4,000 MW, this won’t help much. In Islamabad alone the gap was 190 MW last Thursday causing 150 MW of load shedding to be imposed. By Sunday it had increased to a shortfall of 1,200 MW and after having only had load shedding of 4 – 6 hours, the city is now back to blackouts of up to 12 hours as air conditioning demand rises with the hotter weather.

In Karachi the daily shortfall of 350 MW is coming with 8-10 hours of unannounced blackouts. (Hat tip to Energy Shortage). The Prime Minister still believes that load shedding can be ended this year. Part of the problem in Karachi, apparently, is that the power company has been taken over by a Saudi company who then sold it, but the new owners have yet to take possession. None of the problems have apparently been tackled.

And just to return to Russia for a moment, I had always remembered that before things got unpleasant in Iraq, Russia had been on its way to getting a sizeable chunk of the energy in that country. Turns out that they are now back
A Russian consortium including oil group Lukoil signed a $3.7 billion deal to develop Iraq's West Qurna oil field in 1996, when Saddam Hussein was in power.

"The goal has been set to restore the contracts concluded between Russian and Iraqi companies before the war," Energy Minister Sergei Shmatko told Reuters, adding that a working group on the issue would convene in the near future. . . . .
Saddam's government tore up the Lukoil deal in 2002, months before the invasion, saying the Russian company had done no work at West Qurna since signing it and had failed to fulfil its contractual obligations.

JP Morgan said in March last year that, according to Russian estimates, production at the field was expected to peak at 700,000 barrels per day, and reserves could total between 4.5 billion and 7.3 billion barrels.

Read more!

Saturday, April 11, 2009

Carbon Credits - or Farming in North Dakota

Courtesy of Anthony Watts I am posting this story from his Web Page (Watts Up With That) today, since it relates to the ongoing Carbon Credit discussion.

Simply put the National Farmers Union Carbon Credit Program sells the “credit” that farmers in, say North Dakota, create when they carry out various different farming practices that don’t generate as much carbon dioxide. For example if you practice “no-till” farming of corn and soybeans, then you don’t, obviously, use a tractor to till and thus don’t generate as much carbon dioxide. (By leaving the untilled soil and remaining material in the soil undisturbed so that it does not emit carbon dioxide, and methane and additional carbon dioxide are not emitted - coincidentally it is usually good farming practice since it reduces soil erosion and helps hold nutrients in the soil). Thus, for example, as Bloomberg points out, a farmer who does not till 800 acres can save 470 tons of carbon (dioxide). This then becomes a credit that can be sold, and is apparently currently worth about $3,000 a year.

Thus a site that generates a large quantity of carbon can buy these “offsets” from the farmers saving carbon, and set that against their own production. The North Dakota Farmers Union of some 3,900 members, apparently shared some $9 million last year, up from $2.6 million in 2007. However, if the farmers are doing this already, and for other reasons, that does not stop them selling the credit and taking the money. Except that Anthony gives the story of one farmer that has changed his mind. It is reproduced with his permission.




I have changed my mind about participating in the carbon credit program. And have resolved to give the money I received to St Jude’s Children’s Hospital.

Here is why.

Recently I sat in the fire hall with a few dozen farmers. We had been invited to hear how we can get paid for carbon credits.
The speaker explained how their satellites can measure the carbon in our land individually and how much money we could get. Then asked for questions.

I asked “what is the source of this money”?

The presenter said it comes from big companies that pollute.

I asked “where do they get this money”? He had no answer.

So I answered for him, asking, “won’t it come from everyone who pays their power bill”? He then agreed and said “that could be”.

I then said isn’t this about the theory of man made global warming? he said “we are not going to talk about that”. Here they are on the prairie soliciting land for carbon credits tempting us with free money.

I believe that agreeing to take their money means you agree with taxing cattle gas also, because methane is a greenhouse gas 20 times more powerful than carbon. I believe taking this money without considering its source makes us no better than the bankers who lent money to people, knowing they could not pay it back. Collecting their fees then selling the bad loans in bundles to someone else. They did not care where the money came from either.

Let’s be clear.

Carbon is not a new commodity! No new wealth is being created here! Is this the way we want to make a living? Let me ask you, what if their satellites determine that your land has lost carbon? You will get a bill, not a check, right? If you make a tillage pass you will get a bill for emitting carbon, is this not correct?

It is also a fact that this income will, in short order, get built into your land cost. You will keep very little and be left with the burden of another bureaucratic program.

Let’s be honest, we feel compelled to take this money because of the need to be competitive, however we also need to hold true to our values and lead by example that means placing our principals ahead of money.

No good citizen is opposed to using the earth’s resources wisely, however, wisdom means a person who has both intelligence and humility. In my view many of the proponents of man made global warming have the first and lack the second. We are able to exercise our freedom in this country because we have abundant, reliable and affordable power. It is ironic that we sat in front of the flag in that fire hall and considered trading our liberty for money.

I’ll leave you with a quote from Roy Disney:

“Decision making becomes easier when your values are clear to you”

Read more!

Friday, April 10, 2009

Unconventional Gas - Another Conference and info

While I was attending the EIA Conference in Washington, there was a Conference in Fort Worth on Unconventional Gas ( (hat tip Go Haynesville Shale). To illustrate the value of these reserves I am going to take a table from a paper by J. Daniel Arthur and Bobbi Jo Coughlin that shows some of this information.

From Arthur and Coughlin (pdf)

Their paper deals with the water and other fluids used in hydrofracing the shale, and I will return to it, in a later post. But first notes that I picked up about the Unconventional Gas Conference, starting at Go Haynesville Shale. . Petrohawk gave a paper in which, based on the results of 15 wells in the Haynesville, leads them to predict an average ultimate recovery of 7.5 bcfg for each well which has led them to predict (with 2 offset wells from each current producer) they have a reserve of 150 bcf proven . Last year, before these numbers came out, an analyst for JP Morgan commented
Brian Kuzma, E&P analyst for JPMorgan Securities Inc., says 5-Bcfe wells suggest Haynesville leasehold is worth $40,000-plus per acre. "These wells only cost $5- to $6 million each, which would mean that these reserves would be worth some $1.25 per thousand cubic feet in the ground, using $7.50 gas prices. Given a 5-Bcf well--4 Bcf after royalties--on 120 acres, this equates to $42,000 an acre in value."
Given the enhanced production that Petrohawk are now claiming, that increases these values accordingly.

UPDATE: I have added a link to the second part of Austin Eudaly's coverage of the Conference, and a note on a biomethane development.


Initial production from these wells can range up to 20 mcf/day, with the Petrohawk 15 averaging some 18 mcf although I have not heard any numbers on the decline rates of the wells. We will have to see if they follow the Barnett pattern. It also depends where in the field that you are, since some in North Caddo Parish are reported as coming in quite low. One problem with having wells that productive is that the gas has to go somewhere and at that volume flow, and that number of wells the existing pipelines will not be able to cope. The Tiger pipeline won’t be available until 2011.The City of Shreveport will however be using some of the gas to fuel a new set of buses, purchased with the Stimulus money.. The buses cost over $100,000 more to buy, but will be economic over the longer haul, and they should show up in about 15 months.

In the first paper at the Conference Andy Hopwood, the BP America Vice President gave a few bullet points that Austin Eudaly recorded. As I mentioned in reporting on the EIA Conference, there is anticipated to be a surge in LNG supplies coming out of the Middle East this year. The number is in the 8 -10 bcf/day range and there is some question as to where that will go. Depending on the market much of it may go to Europe or China, but any remaining may well enter the US.

BP will be using America to learn about exploiting gas shales, it is one of the ten flagship technologies that BP has identified for special investment and they expect to take the experience in the US and apply it in places such as Australia, where similar shales can be found. However he reminded the 600 strong audience that conventional gas wells still produce 50% of American gas (which is an interesting decline in itself). Further, though BP has a position in the Haynesville the current glut has caused them to delay any new drilling.

That glut, which was foreseen by a report by Gail at TOD, is likely to be transient, given the short life of most of the gas shale wells, and the rapid drop (to less than 50%) of the number of rigs still operating. The price is now at $3.50 (Henry Hub) (per million btu or kcf) and shows no sign of slowing its steady decline. The weekly EIA report, however does note that some fertilizer operations are restarting with the lower price and this may start to form a floor to further price drops. However with gas being added to storage, even with a cooler temperatures, there is still more than enough to go around.

Update Austin Eudaly has updated his report from the Unconventional Gas Conference, with a report on the paper by Thomas Gardner of Simmons and Co, on the gas glut, (Sensibly describing how it came about and warning that things won’t get better until 2010) and one by Andrew Littlefair of Clean Energy Fuels Corporation, who is a close aide to T. Boone Pickens. The company is the largest provider of natural gas for transportation in North America. If you remember part of Picken’s Plan is to replace the use of natural gas for electricity generation by installing wind turbines. In consequence the freed up natural gas can be used for transportation. The talk covered a lot of the technical aspects of the gas location and the economics of the process, but Austin chose not to cover that.

Meanwhile Clean Energy Fuels has signed an agreement to sell biomethane produced from a landfill in McCommas Bluff to Shell Energy, who will supply it to a utility for power generation. The volume is anticipated to be 4,500 million btu’s (4.5 mcf) per day. The landfill is owned by the City of Dallas and will close in 2042, but is expected to continue to produce gas for at least 30 years after that.


Read more!