Monday, May 11, 2009

Nabucco, or is the Great Gas Game turning into a waltz?

It seems as though, whenever things are relatively quiet in the energy world, which they currently seem to be, then all one has to do is type Gazprom into Google search box, and there will be some interesting snippet.

And lo, it appears that Gazprom is looking into a take-over one of the Hungarian gas pipeline networks. Now that is not what the initial part of the post says, where it notes that the Hungarians are switching their gas purchases from a company (RosUkrEnergo) (RUE) that purchased Russian gas through Ukraine, to a company known as Rosgas AG. As part of the fallout from the January dispute between Russia and Ukraine RUE lost that business, and now Hungary has found a new middleman, Rosgas.
The immediate suspicion is that RosGas AG is yet another in a long line of shadowy intermediary companies created by Firtash and Gazprom. However, in the case of RosGas this may mask a possible attempt by Gazprom to cut gas supplies to Firtash's Emfesz, as a precursor to a company takeover - vastly increasing its share of the Hungarian domestic gas distribution network.

This becomes of some importance when one looks at the relative prospects of the two alternate paths for new gas to reach Western Europe – South Stream and Nabucco. South Stream is being increasingly pushed by Gazprom. The pipeline will bring gas under the Black Sea, and pass through Serbia and Slovenia before reaching Austria. However Eni, who is a 50% partner with Gazprom in this stage of its development, is upset that Gazprom is keeping it out of the negotiations with Serbia and Slovenia. Both countries are anticipated to sign agreements with Gazprom in the near future, without Eni, for gas supplies from South Stream.

And this may be where Hungary comes in, since the competing Nabucco pipeline goes through Hungary to get to the Austrian hub. So that if Gazprom controls the Hungarian pipelines, and can stop competitors’ gas flowing through them (a fact they used to get TNK-BP out of the rich Kovytka field after TNK-BP had developed it.) It is yet another couple of nails in the Nabucco coffin.

Earlier this week, with a fanfare celebrating the coming signature of the Nabucco agreement to run gas through the pipeline across Turkey it looked as though the pipeline was moving rather rapidly forward. However, buried within the story is the backing off of European funding
The European Commission is proposing to scale back its support for the Nabucco project to 200 million euros ($268 million) from 250 million euros, Tarradellas said in February. The aid would be channeled through the European Investment Bank.
At the same time, the last paragraph is interesting.
Friday's statement, signed by leaders of the EU, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Turkey and Egypt, also said the EU and Egypt should "agree on specific projects in developing Egypt's gas reserves and export potential for the EU." It said it was signed "in the presence of the representatives of Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan."The statement also called for a memorandum of understanding on energy between the EU and Iraq "as soon as possible." Barroso said a preliminary energy accord with Iraq was "imminent."
There are nuggets in that paragraph – first the pipeline cannot be effective without the gas from Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. But none of them signed the document. Further Azerbaijan does not think that the project is feasible without Turkmenistan. The Turks will get paid for their trouble
The Turkish government has been driving a hard bargain, insisting on collecting a "tax" on the gas being pumped and demanding 15 percent of the transit gas at discounted prices. These requests have been rejected by the European Commission, the executive branch of the 27-nation bloc, delaying the 9 billion-euro project. More than half of the pipeline is to be located in Turkey.
But getting them on board helps negate the pressure that Russia (read Gazprom) is applying to discourage the “stans” from selling Nabucco their gas.

So as steps in the Great Game you could say that Europe took the first by planning Nabucco, then Russia took the second by stopping an adequate supply availability through pressure on Turkmenistan etc. Europe now gets the third, since with the pipeline running through Turkey they can (if politics allows) run connections into Iran, Egypt and Iraq. And before the step is completed Russia moves to step on their toes and gain control of the Hungarian section, thereby taking the fourth.

With Austria involved, maybe this part of the game is turning into a waltz – but with constantly changing partners - we shall see.

Read more!

Sunday, May 10, 2009

Geologic Time, Oil Formation and Secretary Chu

Last week ,as Climate Audit caught, the Seretary of Energy was asked about how oil and gas got into the Arctic Rocks. Now there is a little catch to the question, in that for oil to be formed the local environment has to be quite warm particularly relative to today’s Arctic temperatures (as explained below). Thus, to explain how the oil got there, the Secretary would have to admit that there was a period when the Arctic was warmer than today. However Dr Chu did not want to give that answer, and so he proclaimed that the rock and oil-forming algae were deposited elsewhere and then migrated, under Continental Drift, until they ended up in the Arctic. Steve gave a condensed answer pointing out how wrong the Secretary is on this, but I thought I would use the error as a base for explaining the origins of oil and natural gas in a post that I can then relate to later.

The majority of world opinion on the matter, has concluded that oil and natural gas originated in the bodies of small organisms, such as modern algae, which can include up to around 56% lipid material (their version of fat). This is referred to occasionally as the biotic source, as opposed to an alternate theory, the “abiotic” theory. This latter theory, which came out of Russia and gained some acceptance in the West, in essence says that oil is generated deep underground by chemical reactions, similar to the Fischer-Tropsch process used to make synthetic oil. While the relevance of this process to oil supply has been disputed, it relies in part on the idea that there are deep pools of oil that fill old reservoirs back up after they are depleted and that if we just drilled deep enough to find them we would have an almost inexhaustible supply. And the catch with that relates to the formation of oil and gas through the biotic explanation.


The biotic explanation for oil and gas formation proposes several steps along the way. First we have the rivers and shallow seas where the algae flourished and died. Sinking to the bottom they mixed with the sediment that is also deposited in such places (and which can be seen in parts of the world today). With time, as with the formation of coal, the sedimentary beds that hold the nascent hydrocarbon fuels are buried deeper. With an increasing depth of burial comes an increase in pressure and temperature. As a very rough rule I use 1 psi of pressure for each foot of burial, and 1 degreeF for every 60 ft of depth startin at 60 deg at 60 ft. So that, for example, at a depth of 3,000 ft the ground pressure is 3,000 psi and the temperature will be 110 deg F.

An early step along the way, as our hydrocarbon starts to cook is its transformation to a kerogen. This is the “oil” of the oil shales of Colorado, New Mexico and Utah. It is not yet a liquid and does not flow. To get to that stage it has to be buried deeper and heated longer. That is what Shell is planning to emulate with their process for oil recovery from the shale. By inserting long heaters into holes down through the rock, and raising the temperature to 650 – 700 deg F and holding at that temperature for 2-3 years they hope to complete the transformation. The temperature is higher than that which would be needed for the natural process, because the process must happen faster. With nature and depending on the part of the world you are in (since the geothermal gradient varies) the transition will occur when beds lie in the 3,000 ft to 15,000 depth.) (Temperatures up to 300 deg F range. ) This depth range is often referred to as the oil window, since shallower rocks aren’t cooked well enough and we get kerogen, and if the rock goes deeper then the higher temperatures will “crack” the oil into natural gas.

(Which is where the problem of deeper pools of oil for abiotic oil comes up, since the deeper pools that the theory calls for would exist at depths where the oil would be cooked into gas, and thus no longer available to supply the oil).

As the oil heats it also thins and becomes less sticky so that it can start to slide through the grains of the surrounding rock, passing along small cracks and being pushed up, in part by the water that was trapped in the rock with it, and which starts to collect below the oil. The oil will move up through the layers of rock until it either reaches the surface, or it is trapped below a rock which does not have the passageways (permeability) wide enough for the oil and water to pass through.

Similarly the deeper deposits that have turned into gas will also begin to move up until they too are trapped beneath an impermeable cover or cap rock.

OK, so when did this happen? Well it depends on the place you’re at. But, for example if we go up to the North Slope of Alaska, the rocks that generated the oil are known as source rocks, and the USGS has identified rocks of the Triassic (the Shublick) ; the Jurassic (Kingak) and the Cretaceous periods may all have contributed oil.

Source USGS

Now a quick peek at a geologic column tells us that these are periods of the Mezozoic Era which ran from the end of the Cretaceous ( 65 million years ago) through the Jurassic (ending 165 million years ago) to the Triassic which ended 208 million years ago. They are younger than the Carboniferous, when coal beds were laid down, by some 40 million years or more.

However, to get back to Dr Chu’s point about Continental Drift having carried the oil bearing rocks up to Alaska, after they were formed, if you go to any of the models which show how the plates have moved, the North American plate (which includes Alaska) was already up in place as far as the North is concerned (but then drifted West) by the beginning of the Jurassic.

So while this was a good try by Dr Chu, a Climate Warming devotee, to get around some geological truths, the facts argue against him. (Not to mention more recent findings within the Holocene, our current geological Era), but we'll save those for another day.
.

Read more!

Saturday, May 9, 2009

Jatropha, algae and camelina oils

If you had not gathered this before, then you should know that I have been favorably impressed with the potential of algae as a future source of biofuels. However I recognize that there is a considerable amount of research and business development and growth that will have to occur before such fuel makes a significant impact in the market place. Of the other alternative biofuel sources, I was also considerate of jatropha, which seemed to have some significant potential. The fuel comes from the nuts which the shrub produces, and since it can be grown on quite poor land, and in some countries is already in use a fencing plant I anticipated that its potential would be increasingly recognized. Well it has not quite turned out the way that I thought it would, at least not yet.

And so some comments on what has, and has not happened. Jatropha seems to have its own slogan “Soil to Oil” with a Center for Jatropha Promotion & Biodiesel located in Rajasthan in India. Jatropha curcus is a shrub or small tree that can grow on poor to marginal land in tropical parts of the world, growing to a height of perhaps 15 ft. It produces a nut in clusters of around 10, and the nuts contain seeds which are about 37% of an oil that will run a diesel engine without further refining.

Thr oil has been used in a 50:50 blend with jet fuel to power one engine of an Air New Zealand 747 on a 2-hr flight last December 30th. The oil has a lower freezing temperature than jet fuel, and has been estimated to cost around $43 per barrel. This flight was followed, on January 7th by a Continental Airlines flight which used a 737-800, and a mix of oil from jatropha and alga. The flight saw a 3% gain in fuel use by the engine using the biofuel. The algae oil came from Sapphire Energy the jatropha came from Terasol Energy. The biofuel was mixed 50:50 with jet fuel, and there were no modifications made to the engine.

The success of the test has encouraged Sapphire, who are now predicting that they will be able to produce 1 million gal/year (65 barrels/day) of diesel and jet fuel, rising to 10 million gallons (650 bd) by 2018 and 1 billion gallons (65 kbd) by 2025. Sapphire is based in San Diego.

Terasol supplies both oil and feedstocks, concentrating, at the moment, on jatropha and castor bean oil.

Japanese Airlines carried out their own test on January 30th. The Japanese flight, an hour-and-a-half long, used a mixture of 84% camelina, under 16% jatropha oil, and under 1% algal oil.

Camelina, (or wild flax) incidentally looks as though it deserves more investigation, since it grows on poor ground and has twice the yield of soy. Further it also has a low gell temperature.
The spent biomass is recognized as a good animal feed, and it grows in places like Kansas and Montana, perhaps alternating with wheat, in which combination it apparently increases the wheat yield by 15%, and gives 100 gallons/acre of oil.
Dr. Bill Schillinger at Washington State University recently described camelina’s business model to Capital Press as: “At 1,400 pounds per acre at 16 cents a pound, camelina would bring in $224 per acre; 28-bushel white wheat at $8.23 per bushel would garner $230.”

Returning to jatropha, the President of Terasol recently answered some questions for Scientific American. He noted that the main problem the fuel now faces is one of scale.
the main obstacle is the lack of research and practice in large-scale commercial cultivation, as well as mechanized harvesting. Currently most jatropha and castor are grown on smaller, independent farms. The second obstacle is yield and unit of input. Research in plant breeding needs to continue in order to improve the quantity and quality of oils being produced.
They see commercial quantities of the jatropha being available in 3-5 years.

The optimistic view of jatropha’s future is becoming less common, even as it is projected as a fuel of the future. There in fact some doubts
Not only was the cultivation of jatropha supposed to absorb more CO2 from the atmosphere than it released, but the miracle tree could also stabilize and restore degraded soils. That’s surely why Scientific American in 2007 called jatropha “green gold in a shrub,” a plant that “seems to offer all the benefits of biofuels without the pitfalls.”

Fast forward a couple of years. By 2009, governments from China to Brazil, along with several major biofuel companies, had planted — or vowed to plant — millions of acres of jatropha. In India alone, the government has announced plans to subsidize an intensive program to plant jatropha for biofuels on 27 million acres of “wastelands” — an area roughly the size of Switzerland.
The problem, again is one of scale. With the average farm being around 12 acres (at 2-300 gal/acre/year) the current gains come mainly from local use, rather than collection to meet larger national goals.

For example in Mali the nation has some 10,000 km of jatropha hedges that yield about 1 kg/meter/year. If all the nuts were collected and processed this would yield around 5 million liters per yr of oil (85.8 bd). Typical village hedge lies between 2 & 15 km, making oil generation very much a local enterprise. It is growing because there has been a move to provide local women with engine powered grain mills, to start small businesses. But the fuel cost was prohibitive. Collecting and processing the nuts can not only provide the needed fuel, but also inject about $3,800 on average, per village per year. As a result local hedges are growing in length, though somewhat slowly (from 5 – 15 km in 8 years.) The projects have also benefitted from development of a shelling machine for the nuts.

But while the growth is commendable, it is nowhere near working at the scale needed to have a significant market impact.

Read more!

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Can politics be removed from biofuel generation?

The Administration has been praised for its move to rely more on science in the generation of policy, and on Tuesday a new group was announced that will work to encourage a new generation of biofuels.
The working group aims to accelerate funding to biofuels producers, in the hopes that they will phase out fossil fuel use at their own plants, instead using biofuels.

The group, which will be headed by the chiefs of the Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Energy and the Department of Agriculture, also exists to encourage a new generation of biofuels made from biomass and other non-corn feedstocks.
Part of the study will, however, try to create a standard for assessing the GHG costs of producing and using the new fuel.
Mirroring a similar change in California, EPA is proposing to measure carbon emissions that come as a result of biofuel production. This includes a complicated and controversial formula that adds in emissions that occur when overseas farmers respond to higher food prices by converting forest and grassland to cropland.

“Life cycle estimates of the greenhouse gas relate to the fuel cycle and land conversion,” said EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson. “This research will be very important to future policies.”
It may well be that the “controversial” formula may take the discussion out of pure science, and give the opportunity to ease politics back into the discussion.

Certainly the Administration recognizes the financial cost, with some $800 million of DoE stimulus money being directed at research, development and the funding of test projects. However $484 million will go to demonstration projects, some of which are already being funded. The major emphasis seems to remain on generating ethanol, though an algae biofuels consortium will also be funded. This is to be followed by $1.1 billion in DoA funds much of that will go to help producers, through the biofuels credit program, restructure their businesses to survive. At present production is down and there is not enough (if any) profit to be made between the price of the corn feedstock and the sale of the ethanol.

The carbon costs of each process, will be calculated by the “controversial” formula, but the calculation was first subjected to “peer revew.” Though I guess that the validity of that process depends on the peers that were used.

In regard to the algae effort the Univ of New Haven are looking for better strains of algae to use. They note that some $195 million was raised for investment in algae work last year.

One of the greater drivers for algal biofuel development is coming from DoD who are anxious to find a replacement source for the jet fuel, on which an increasing percentage of their mobile systems run. DARPA have been taking a lead in developing this research. One of their advances has just been given some publicity
Researchers at the university (UT) have already developed an electromechanical process for extracting oil from an alga cell that is rapid, energy-efficient, free of solvents and less expensive than competing methods. The technique employs electric fields to break open the cell.

Another group of researchers at the university is focused on the science of separations research and is identifying techniques to separate the oil from the algae biomass once it has been released
.
In another development Richard Sayre at theDanforth Center in St Louis has discussed the use of algae that can be milked instead of being destroyed. The goal of the DARPA program is to reduce the cost of the biofuel to $3 a gallon.

The fact that algae make fuel while consuming CO2 is also being presented to Congress at the same time as a new report on the subject is being released. (pdf).

In perhaps a sign of things to come, an ethanol plant in Iowa is going to add some algal photobioreactors to the plant. The algae will take advantage of the water heat and CO2 generated from the ethanol plant, with hopes to use some 60% of the CO2.


Read more!

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Wind in the Rockies is expensive

Government policy can, once decided, be implemented by a combination of laws and financial incentives/disincentives among other means. Thus, for example, when trying to change the ways in which America gets power, the government can limit the amount of coal burned, both by direct fiat, and by making it too expensive (through the cost of permits). The former limit will be established through the caps on the production of GHG, assuming that there is no immediate vast investment in sequestration. There is a fair amount of debate over whether the financial incentive will be through a direct tax or the more indirect route of charging for allocations. Having heard Congressman Waxman’s aide at the EIA meeting, I believe the decision is long over, and that, if anything does come out of this Congress it will be the cap and trade model that will be used.

That having been said, since the nation is growing in numbers, even if per capita use is held constant (as it has sensibly been in California) any reduction in fossil fuel use will need to be replaced with an alternative. At present the most widely touted of these are wind and solar, and the high costs of solar mean that, for many utilities seeking change, wind has been the choice, but even this is, in some cases, proving to be too expensive an option.

Wind farms are becoming more obvious around the country, and their message is strengthened with a steady campaign of adverts. T. Boone Pickens is seen more as a savior than as a salesman. And the Secretary of the Interior currently is pointing out that there is sufficient wind available to replace all the coal-fired power stations in the country. But under all the hype, and after the cranes have come and gone, the change in energy source has to make economic sense. Wind farms will only be established where there is a credible likelihood of their making money for the investors that raise them. The current comments of the Secretary come as hearings get under way around the country.
Salazar said ocean winds along the East Coast can generate 1 million megawatts of power, roughly the equivalent of 3,000 medium-sized coal-fired power plants, or nearly five times the number of coal plants now operating in the United States, according to the Energy Department.

Salazar could not estimate how many windmills might be needed to generate 1 million megawatts of power, saying it would depend on their size and how far from the coast they were located.

Mark Rodgers, a spokesman for Cape Wind, which wants to build a wind farm off Cape Cod, Mass., estimates it would take hundreds of thousands of windmills. The average wind turbine today generates 2 to 5 megawatts per unit, he said.
This is the first of four hearings, and focused on the East Coast. But the potential states most likely to benefit can be judged from the DoI plan to create Regional Energy Permitting Centers.
To expedite production of renewable energy on public lands while protecting land, water, and wildlife, Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar today pledged to create four Renewable Energy Coordination Offices, one each in California, Nevada, Wyoming, and Arizona, along with smaller renewable energy teams in New Mexico, Idaho, Utah, Colorado and Oregon.
You may note that these are all in the West.

While the numbers quoted are large, and the potential benefits of moving to renewable energy are continually being cited, the underlying realities of getting a good return on the investment, at a lower cost than the alternative, is being kept quiet. Unfortunately, as an article in USA Today notes, even with the best will in the world, those benefits don’t always happen. And, in the case of Durango, CO, the utility is moving back to coal, from wind.
For two years, the city of Durango, Colo., bought electricity for all its government buildings from wind farms. The City Council ended that program this year, reverting to electricity derived from coal-burning plants and saving the cash-strapped city about $45,000.

The Durango plan has its roots back in 2007 when the city made the move to wind energy.
Green power currently constitute(d) about 10% of city power purchases. The extra the city pays for green energy will add about $120,000 a year to its electrical bill officials said. But the extra cost will be offset by an energy audit aimed at cutting power consumption. With the wind power option, electric customers pay $1.25 per block of 100-kilowatt-hours in addition to their regular rate. The extra that consumers pay for their power funds investment by power producers in alternative-energy sources such as hydropower, solar and wind. But electricity from all sources flows on the same line. In 2006, Durango used almost 8.15 million kilowatt-hours of power at a cost of $779,000.

At the time, as you may notice, the city recognized that the renewable energy would cost more, but felt that it could make up the difference with improved efficiency. Which is the same sort of argument that we are now getting from the new Administration.

Although the above cite is recent, the change actually occurred last December.
City Manager Ron LeBlanc recommended the city stop buying power from renewable energy sources when it became necessary to cut the 2009 budget by more than $500,000. The city council approved the budget, including his recommendation, earlier this month.

The La Plata electric association charges 80 cents more per 100 kilowatt hours for electricity from solar and wind power. LeBlanc says that adds $45,000 to the city’s annual electric bill.
La Plata does not generate the power itself, but is passing along a program from Tri-State.
The LPEA Green Power program was initiated in 1998 when Tri-State – from which LPEA purchases its power – responded to requests by its member systems, to include a green power option as part of its available resources to end-use consumers. Because of this program, LPEA customers who request purchase of green power receive it at LPEA’s cost from Tri-State, $1.25 per 100 kilowatt-hour block per month. Purchasing one block of Green Power costs consumers less than $.05 per day. To date, LPEA is among the leading purchasers of Green Power in Tri-State’s 44-member cooperative system, supplying nearly 800,000 kilowatt hours of Green Power generation each month.
Tr-State had lowered their costs to 80 cents in January, 2008. . However the company has also carried out an Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) looking at future energy supply, based on anticipated need. That plan concluded:
Tri-State proposes to develop and own two new 700-megawatt supercritical coal-based units at the existing coal-based, 360-megawatt Holcomb Station in western Kansas. The efficient units would include best available control technology to minimize air emissions and activated carbon injection to minimize mercury emissions. The IRP clearly reinforces the need for the first 700-megawatt baseload resource in 2012, which is when Tri-State first unit at Holcomb Station could be online.

Since the first Holcomb unit cannot be brought on line until 2012, Tri-State is left with a significant deficiency in both capacity and energy during the interim period; and its options are somewhat limited. For modeling purposes in this IRP, it is assumed that Tri-State will install combustion turbines (CTs) as soon as possible and purchase energy from the market. However, there are many other options available to Tri-State.
These are the coal-fired power plants that then-Governor Sibelius vetoed three times, with part of her argument being that more than 80% of the energy they would produce would be exported. Which leaves one wondering where the power will come from for Durango, since I am presuming that the turbines are gas-driven, and thus too expensive.

(Um! Yes I know that Durango said that they are going back to coal, and have so moved, but Tri-State still has their supply problem, or will as soon as the economy picks back up without the new stations they were relying on.)

Read more!

Some short notes

The end of the month, and the enforced rest, was going to give me time to catch up on a couple of things, but it turns out that there is a good reason (in the level of medication among others) for the rest, so things will needs must wait. And talking of waiting, it turns out that , despite some earlier predictions to the contrary, spring has been coming later to parts of the Arctic rather than the uniform earlier spring that is usually reported. The location of the relatively earlier warming zone along the southern Norwegian coast makes it appear that the phenomenon may be sea current based).

By the way, also in regard to waiting, the Actress went ahead and ordered her Fusion this weekend, in the same color as the story, but had to travel, and make a number of calls, to find a dealer who had one. Even so the single one on the lot was not quite right, hence the order. We were told to expect a wait of 3-6 months, before delivery. We’ll keep you posted.

Last summer Lausanne became the first Swiss city with an underground metro and there are still plans to move ahead with a more comprehensive metro system for the country, with the goal of allowing a train ride that will take only 12 minutes to get from Zurich to Bern. It was in Zurich, this past weekend that the Nurse became a Grandma, welcome to Pippa Fiona.

Despite heavier than usual snows most of the glaciers in Switzerland are continuing to retreat, but while the headlines are for the one that retreated most (the Gorner retreated 290 m) the average retreat was less than 25 m. No-one makes much mention of the two that advanced.

Read more!

Sunday, May 3, 2009

A quick look at gas and miles travelled

Having missed both This Week in Petroleum, and the monthly release of miles driven, I thought I would just pop these up. Partially because we are seeing a slight pickup in miles driven, in parts of the country, which slowed the drop. (But bear in mind that this plot includes information only up through February.

February miles travelled

Let me just look in more detail at the end of the graph.

Top part of the Curve showing the change in slope.

If we look up at the top, the declining slope of the line is beginning to turn up, a little. When we contrast this with the data from TWIP on gasoline demand, one can see that this is remaining sensibly flat.

(Source EIA)
While the historic pickup that usually applies from April through June is not evident, the slope does appear, if anything, a little positive. But it remains early to make predictions, or do anything much beyond remaining optimistic.


Read more!