Showing posts with label crude and condensate production. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crude and condensate production. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 31, 2014

Tech Talk - Projections 2

It is the end of another year, or more optimistically the start of a new one. Last year I was tempted to make a couple of predictions for the future. And while I can make the case that they were not too wrong, they did not include the drop in oil prices, which has now taken the price of our local gas to below $1.85 a gallon. China has, in recent months, seemed less belligerent about claiming large sections of the China Seas. Whether this has anything to do with the relative success of rigs that have drilled in those waters is something that still remains an unknown.

But it is the changing price of gasoline, itself reflective of the drop in oil prices that is the big news. WTI closed at $53.56 today, and Brent at $57.50 a barrel. Predictions include some who would suggest that the price will continue to fall, until it reaches $20 a barrel, and there it may stay for some time. Well it certainly grabs a headline, but that is about all the value that particular forecast contains. The futures prices suggest that the price has yet to bottom out, though it may be getting close to that value.


Figure 1. Crude oil futures prices (EIA TWIP)

None of the recent news suggests that there will be a further increase in supply to sustain the current imbalance between available supply and demand. Libya is descending even further into a mess, with the oil facilities at the port of Es Sider now being destroyed. The likelihood of significant increases in production and the return to export levels achieved earlier this summer seems increasingly nonexistent. Neither Russia nor Saudi Arabia are likely to increase production, although the latter are continuing to produce the increased volume that they originally put on the market to replace Libyan losses. And so this leaves Iraq and the United States as the key producers who can significantly change the current supply:demand balance in any significant way.

It is probable that, with the agreement between the Kurds and the Central Government now having generated a second payment of $500 million to the KRG that the agreement may be sustained and grow. At present the Kurds are to supply about 550 kbd, of which 300 kbd will travel through the new pipeline to Turkey and thence onto the world market. The rest will be supplied to Baghdad. Meanwhile production in the south (which gets exported through Basra) has seen some increase.

Whether the Kurdish production can increase to over 1 mbd by the end of next year remains open to some doubt, given the ongoing conflict, and the target 6 mbd by the end of the decade for the entire country will likely require changes that the current conflict, which shows no signs of ending, will inhibit.

One of my responses, when the drop in price first started, was to note that the oil supply system has a certain inertia to it. And here I am not talking about the fluctuations in price that one sees in the stock market, and in the price of the crude, but rather in the time that it takes to stop current drilling, postpone future plans and to reduce the production from existing and new developments.

Thus the drop in investment in new production, whether in Russia, Iraq or the United States takes some time to have an impact. Unfortunately for those expecting the price to continue to fall, in the face of the overabundant supply, the situation has changed since historic times, where well production was relatively stable and the oversupply situation was corrected by shutting in production (mainly by Saudi Arabia). Even then it was the perception of the response that drove price rebounds, rather than the immediate reality of the changes.

The system this time is different. The increase in production in the United States has been sustained, and over the last two years has produced more than 2 mbd more than at the start of that period.


Figure 2. US crude oil production over the past two years. (EIA TWIP)

The rig count in North Dakota has already fallen to 170 rigs compared with 187 at this time last year. Concern about the oil price has led companies to cut their investment plans for next years, in some case by 20% so that the rig count is likely to continue to fall. And with the short life at high production values for most wells that will soon affect production. The North Dakota Oil and Gas Division of DMR shows the consequences of this:


Figure 3. Future production estimates from the ND DMR Oil and Gas Division.

The blue line requires about 225 rigs in continuous action, so that won’t happen. By the same token the black line is with no more drilling, and that won’t happen either. The result will be somewhere in between, probably moving the peak out beyond the current projection, but also lowering it as the existing baseline drops with less wells significantly contributing. (Bear in mind it is taking 11,892 wells to sustain current production levels.) But in the short term the line will likely dip down until the price rebounds.

The question now becomes how soon that drop in US production will become evident, and have some impact. I doubt that it will be before June of 2015.

On which note may I wish all readers a Happy, Healthy, Successful and Prosperous 2015.

Read more!

Friday, September 16, 2011

A gentle cough for CBS and the National Petroleum Council

I was flipping through the news channels last night and came in on the tail end of a CBS story about billions of barrels of oil in Texas. Having missed the introduction, it was not until this morning that I discovered that it was a story about the Eagle Ford Shale.
Energy companies are rushing to the area to tap deposits that could produce up to 12 billion barrels of oil, and enough natural gas to power every American household for at least five years.

By 2020, that number (of new jobs) is expected to increase to 66,000.
I remember writing a short post on the Eagle Ford last December pointing out that the field was currently being more actively developed in the “wet gas” region where the Natural Gas Liquids (NGL) content is high, since this was more profitable than the deeper “dry gas” sections. But I did not remember the numbers being that high.

Being curious about them, a check at the EagleFordShale Web site suggests that the CBS report was triggered by a report from the National Petroleum Council, which was released yesterday. That report had been requested by Energy Secretary Chu to
reassess the North American natural gas and oil resources supply chain and infrastructure potential, and the contribution that natural gas can make in a transition to a lower carbon fuel mix . . . . .(provide) advice on policy options that would allow prudent development of North American natural gas and oil resources consistent with government objectives of environmental protection, economic growth, and national security (and) the United Sates sees a future in which valuable domestic energy resources are responsibly produced to meet the needs of American energy consumers consistent with national, environmental, economic and energy security goals, ... [and the United States] has the opportunity to demonstrate global leadership in technological and environmental innovation. Accordingly, I request the Council’s advice on potential technology and policy actions capable of achieving this vision.
The report notes that “The United States and Canada together produce 4% more oil than Russia, the world’s largest producer.”

Leading World Oil Producers (NPC using BP Statistical Review).


Further, together with Canada, the report points out that the United States produces over 25% of global natural gas production, with the arrival of shale gas being the game changer that may provide over 100 years of supply at today’s demand rates.

Leading World Natural Gas Producers (NPC using BP Statistical Review)

Yet it is in the discussion of those reserve numbers that the shaky timber on which the NPC case is build becomes apparent. When discussing future oil production it notes:
One source is tight oil, found in geological formations where the oil does not easily flow through the rock, such as in the Bakken formation of North Dakota, Saskatchewan, Montana, and Manitoba. Tight oil has also benefited from technologies similar to those used for shale gas, including hydraulic fracturing. Over the next 20 years, tight oil production could continue to grow. A second potentially large supply source is in new offshore areas, particularly in the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic and Pacific coasts of the United States and Canada. Access to and potential development of these new U.S. areas would require an Executive Branch level directive to include such areas in the 2012–2017 Leasing Program. New offshore areas could provide both natural gas and oil in significant quantities to supplement the continuing strong production in the Gulf of Mexico. Third, new Arctic oil and natural gas supply have a potential of the equivalent of over 200 billion barrels of oil. This is in addition to existing oil supply and proven natural gas reserves on the Alaska North Slope. The new Arctic resources could yield significant supply after 2025. Fourth, another very large long-term oil supply source lies in the shale oil deposits of Colorado, Utah, and Wyoming. The development of these billions of barrels of oil from these new resource areas will require sustained investment, substantial advances in technology, and environmental risk management systems and approaches.
The report also supplies this estimate of the available natural gas, showing several estimates.

Estimates of the Technically Recoverable Natural Gas Available in the United States. (NPC )

I have recently written of the Bakken Shale, and the problems that I see with its long term production. I have also similarly discussed some of the problems with the Arctic development and the potential size of the reserves available. ) In the later case I noted that the recent USGS report had downgraded, as an illustration, their initial estimate of 10 billion barrels of oil being technically recoverable from the National Petroleum Reserve, to a current estimate of 500 million barrels of economically recoverable oil. That percentage difference between the actual recoverable, relative to the technically recoverable is in line with a 6.9% estimate of the economically recoverable (relative to technically) volumes of natural gas, which I pointed out when I reviewed the EIA Shale Gas report.

If one were to look at these numbers in that light (though the actual detailed resource section with its break down is not yet available from NPC) then the numbers become more credible. Unfortunately it makes the estimates of the contributions that the industry will make to national energy security and job creation a whole lot weaker, if the numbers are only one-twentieth of those which are currently being thrown around.

Unfortunately the report goes on to spend much more time discussing the environmental aspects of oil and gas recovery, and emphasizing such things are the reduction in pad size in the Arctic:

Change in Arctic Pad Size with Improved Technology (API

There is not that much that is encouraging in the way of new technology that is anticipated to come on line to increase the percentages of natural gas and oil that can be recovered, and the report does comment on the need for more graduates as the current work force retires – a need that is not being adequately filled.

It is a weak straw on which to build the projections that CBS used.

Read more!

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

OGPSS - Gulf of Mexico production, and hurricanes

The summer brings back Hurricane season, with the threat that such storms bring to the oil and gas well operations in the Gulf of Mexico. And the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has noted that
The Atlantic basin is expected to see an above-normal hurricane season this year, according to the seasonal outlook issued by NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center . . . . 3 to 6 major hurricanes (Category 3, 4 or 5; winds of 111 mph or higher)
The lessons of this vulnerability were, perhaps, more than most years, evident in 2005. The first sign of problems came with the arrival of Hurricane Dennis in July. It was a storm which severely damaged the BP deep water Thunder Horse drilling platform.

Thunder Horse after Hurricane Dennis (Prof Goose)

As that season wore on, the vulnerability of the platforms in the Gulf, and the refineries that border it, were exposed in more intensity with the passage of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. These threats and their analysis were one of the factors that helped, in that formative year, to bring an audience to the pages of The Oil Drum. The Gulf is now home to thousands of wells, which, as the evidence from the Deepwater Horizon disaster last year reminded us, has moved further and further away from shore. That vulnerability is perhaps illustrated by a map, showing the path of Hurricane Rita through the oil platforms off the Texas and Louisiana coasts.

Path of Hurricane Rita through off-shore Gulf production facilities (The Oil Drum) (Each dot is a production unit)

Back in the 1930’s and ‘40’s it was the very gradual deepening of the seabed in the Gulf, that allowed the first oil drillers to venture, through the swampy regions of the Mississippi Delta and then on out into the waters of the Gulf. There had been some drilling from piers out in California and similar constructions were also tried along the Louisiana shore, as the prospects for success tempted companies away from the coast. However, as they did so the rigs faced the challenge, as they do today, of surviving in regions where Hurricanes are not uncommon. The industry was helped in this development since there were no major hurricanes that moved through the regions of most intense drilling, from the first wells in 1945 until 1964 when Hurricane Hilda arrived. And even when that hurricane struck on October 3rd, it only damaged three locations, at Eugene Island and Ship Shoals 149 and 199, with a total of some 11,869 bbl of oil being spilled due to the storm.

Gulf of Mexico showing regional features (Geoexpro)

The first pier-based platform had been built out into the Gulf of Mexico at McFaddin Beach, south of Port Arthur, Texas after having been approved by the Secretary of War, on July 8, 1937. The pier was a mile long, with three rigs at the far end, but it only drilled dry holes and was destroyed in a hurricane in 1938. More widely recognized was the first well to be drilled out of sight of land. This was the Creole platform near Cameron, which was a mile out-to-sea, an hour-an-a-half trip by shrimp boat at the time. The water was only 18 ft deep and the well, initially drilled by Pure Oil and Superior Petroleum, (later Kerr McGee, and then Anadarko) sat some 15-ft above the water level. Initial production was 600 bd from a depth of 9,400 ft. It was damaged by a hurricane in 1940, but survived and produced more than four-million barrels since through directional drilling.

Kemnac Rig 16 drilling the first offshore well in the Gulf of Mexico (Kerr-McGee via Penn Energy)

As was the case with California there was initially some controversy over who owned the rights to minerals off-shore and in 1953 Congress passed the Submerged Lands Act, which gave the rights to the states for the first three miles offshore, (the range of a smooth bore cannon at one time) and then the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act which gave the rights for the more offshore land to the Federal Government. This settling of the disputes encouraged further drilling and while there were already 70 rigs, drilling at depths up to 70 ft of water, the years after 1953 saw the development of a variety of different rigs for drilling in ever deeper water. Designs to cope with hurricanes also progressed, so that by the time of Hurricane Flossy in 1956 rigs were relatively safe. It was followed by Audrey in 1957, ranked as the sixth deadliest hurricane in US history, which came ashore at Cameron, and killed 416 people, but caused $16 million in damage offshore, with no fatalities.

Path of Hurricane Flossy in September 1956. (Note I have referenced the web pages showing the storm paths under the Hurricane name in that which follows).

Technology was, however, allowing rigs to work in ever deeper water, 100 ft of water in 1957, 225 feet by 1965, and 300 ft in 1969. With this increase in range came increased production, which had reached 2 mbd, but it also exposed more rigs to the threat from larger storms. Hilda, formed in 1964, caused $100 million in damage and effectively destroyed 18 platforms,; Betsy in September 1965 had the distinction of financially impacting a future President of the United States.
On September 9th, the day Hurricane Betsy struck, MAVERICK was located 20 miles off the Louisiana Coast in 220 ft of water. The following day an inspection showed Zapata’s three other rigs were undamaged, but the MAVERICK had vanished. This was the largest single loss that the domestic offshore drilling industry sustained in this or any other hurricane. . . . . .The MAVERICK loss was a substantial one for Zapata. This was our newest rig and one of our very best contracts. . .
(George H.W. Bush, “My Life in Letters and Other Writings.”) (The insurance check was for $5.7 million).

Camille in 1969 was the largest storm to hit the USA in the 20th century. It did about $100 million in offshore damage, including sinking three up-to-date rigs designed to survive those storms. (Camille was a Category 5). Onshore the damage exceeded $1 billion. This was the hurricane that taught the industry that they had to design rigs that could not only withstand waves more than 70-ft high, but has also to consider that the seabed itself might move under the force of the storm.

Fortunately such storms have proved to be relatively rare, and the “three strikes” of Dennis, Katrina and Rita in 2005 have not been repeated since. Yet the industry remains highly vulnerable to such storms. As the second figure shows, the Gulf has become increasingly filled with production platforms. In 2008 this region was hit by hurricanes Gustav at the start of September and Ike two weeks later. Even though these were weaker storms their impact was significant.
Effective August 2008, there were more than 3,800 production platforms in the Gulf, ranging in size from single well caissons in 10 feet of water up to a large, complex facility in 7,000 feet of water. The MMS estimates about 2,127 production platforms were exposed to hurricane conditions from Gustav and Ike, carrying winds greater than 74 miles per hour.

Final results of the agency’s assessment of destroyed and damaged facilities from these two storms indicate that 60 platforms were destroyed. These included some platforms that had been reported earlier to have extensive damage.

In comparison, 115 platforms were destroyed by the Rita-Katrina wallop in 2005.

The platforms designated as destroyed following Gustav and Ike produced 13,657 barrels of oil and 96,490,000 cubic feet of gas per day, or 1.05 percent of the oil and 1.3 percent of the gas produced daily.
Part of the reduction in damage came from lessons learned from Katrina/Rita.
Mobile Offshore Drilling Units (MODUs) that previously had to have eight mooring lines were now required to have 12 and, in some cases, 16 mooring lines,” Angelico said. “In ’08, 18 moored MODUs were in the path of hurricane force winds, and two went adrift, which represented 15 percent of the rigs out there. In Katrina and Rita, 63 percent of the rigs went adrift.’

There are additional impacts from these storms. The Gulf continues to produce about 27% of the nation’s oil, and 15% of the natural gas. Those fuels must be brought ashore and, in the case of oil, refined. Refineries lie inshore all along the Gulf Coast, and if flooded can take months to be brought back on line. Given the growing reliance that the country places on production from these regions makes us all vulnerable to the season.

Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) Crude and Condensate as an annual volume and percentage of national production. (BOEMRE)

Last October OCS crude and condensate production averaged 1.52 mbd, which comprised 28% of the estimated US production.

Offshore Natural gas production as an annual volume and percentage of national production (BOEMRE)

Last October natural gas production averaged 5.6 bcf/day which was 8.9% of estimated national production.

There is a significant production from smaller, older wells, while the new fields are found in deeper waters further into the Gulf, and so that is where I will venture next time.

Read more!