Showing posts with label polyethylene oxide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label polyethylene oxide. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Waterjetting 32d - Cutting with polymer in the water

In the recent past I have written about the use of polymers in high-pressure jets and that they can significantly improve jetting performance, with no additional changes in the power or pump and equipment used in the work. This is because of two different effects that the polymers have. Firstly they reduce turbulence in the flow from the pump to the nozzle, reducing pressure loss and increasing fluid flow, for the same pump power. As a practical consequence since the fluid flow will be greater for the same pump pressure, this will require that a larger orifice diameter be used to handle the greater, or – for the same flow rate and nozzle diameter, the pump can be operated at a lower pressure.


Figure 1. Comparison between a conventional jet and one containing the polymer additive marketed as SUPERWATER. (after Glenn Howells)

This is not immediately apparent, since the jet carrying the polymer appears smaller, but this is due to the second effect of the polymer, which is to tend to glue the water together, so that it is not dispersed as easily by the surrounding fluid – air in this case. In fact, for the same pump pressure and orifice diameter the lower jet will be operating at a higher pressure (since there is less pressure loss in the line) and there will be more water coming out of the polymer-supplied orifice at a higher velocity. But because it is not spreading into the air, it appears smaller.

This will improve the cohesion of the jet as it moves away from the jet, and as noted in an earlier post, this means that the jet will cut to a greater range from the jet, since it maintains the required critical pressure further.



The impact that the more coherent jet has on performance can be seen where the jet is used to cut into two different types of limestone, one oolitic and one crystalline.


Figure 3. Depths of cut of the polymer-containing jet (left) and plain waterjet, operating at the same pump pressure, nozzle diameter and standoff distance (Glenn Howells)

Note that at the distance where the normal waterjet has broken into droplets (as seen by the nature of the cut surface) and the jet has barely enough energy to remove the surface layer, where the jet contains polymer it retains the ability to cut.

Further, and this is more critical where cut quality is more important, the jet cut is much straighter and cleaner than the dispersed and wider normal cut. This can be seen where a different, more crystalline limestone has been cut closer to the nozzle.


Figure 4. Change in the cut shape to a narrower, deeper cut where polymer is added to the jet stream (rhs)in cutting limestone. (after Glenn Howells)

The benefit of the improved performance changes therefore with the distance of the target from the nozzle, with the more dramatic improvement being seen as the target gets further from the nozzle. Looking at the data from the original work that we did in Leeds, back in the early days of this study, this can perhaps be better realized through the use of a 3-D plot.


Figure 5. Improvement in cutting performance as a function of distance from the nozzle and jet pressure.

Note that, in these trials, the polymer improved the jet performance relatively more at lower pressures and greater standoff distance. Part of the reason for this (in hindsight close to 50-years after running the tests) is that when the jet was cutting at the lower pressures it was closer to the threshold pressure of the rock and this any drop in jet pressure had a more significant impact on cut depth than occurred at the higher pressures, where the gain was not relative to such a low benchmark.

For a number of years, until our research took us into fields where use of the polymer was precluded for several reasons, we routinely used a polymer (generally Superwater, marketed by Berkeley Chemical) rather than Polyox because it gave a relatively consistent and significant improvement in performance plus, being a liquid, it was relatively simple and inexpensive to buy a small metering unit (about the size of a small case) which would feed the polymer into the water supply line to the pump at the required concentration – typically 0.1 to 0.3%.

It tends to work better in improving abrasive jet cutting when it is used with a Direct Injection of Abrasive (DIAjet) or Abrasive Slurry Jet (ASJ) system than with conventional abrasive waterjet (AWJ) systems. The reason for this is that the AWJ system has the abrasive fed into the water stream at the mixing chamber just before the jet leaves the nozzle to strike the target. Within the mixing chamber the abrasive has to penetrate into the waterjet stream in order to acquire the jet velocity, and to distribute across the jet and give an even cut on the target.

Where the abrasive is feeding in from one side of the jet and the waterjet stream is more coherent, it becomes more difficult for the abrasive to penetrate the stream, and if the design is not adjusted accordingly, the cutting performance can be diminished, particularly relative to the gain that can be achieved where the combination is carried out effectively.

On the other hand with the ASJ systems the abrasive is mixed with the water far upstream of the nozzle and the are already thoroughly mixed together, so that the added cohesion of the jet will help to provide the acceleration that the particles need to reach close to the waterjet velocity, and achieve the improved cutting performance required.

Where an ultrahigh pressure jet does not contain abrasive, the polymer can be of benefit as a means of improving cut quality – as evidenced from this comparison in cutting a shoe sole pattern, both with and without the Superwater polymer.


Figure 6. Shoe sole cut comparison with and without Superwater. Note the smoother cut, with less fraying of the back side of the cut with the polymer. (after Glenn Howells)

Read more!

Saturday, April 25, 2015

Waterjetting 32c - more tests with polymers

In the last post on this topic I pointed out that one of early drivers to the use of long-chain polymers in water came from the reduction in friction that it provided to fluid flow through long pipes. In many instances this has been the driving force for the selling of the product, and in industries such as oil well drilling and fracking the reduction in friction down long relatively small diameter drilling pipe has been a significant selling argument.

The cohesion of the jet, once it leaves the nozzle, is a secondary consideration in overall economics, yet in some applications, such as the cleaning of down-hole completion screens, the ability of a polymer-laden waterjet to penetrate through the pressurized fluid in an oil well to reach and clean the screen has been the main reason that the market developed.


Figure 1. Improved jet power underwater when polymer is added (after Zublin)

One of the first steps to be addressed was the practical considerations as to how we got the polymer into fluid that made up the jet stream. The original polymer that I used was polyethylene oxide (Polyox) which was marketed in the form of small prills of chemical. The problem that we were then faced with is that, when these are just dumped into a container full of water, that the outer edge of each prill soaked up some water, became gel-like and adhesive, and stuck to the next particle, in a way that made a large collective lump that was very difficult to dissolve into the surrounding water flow. Even when the particles were fed in slowly into a fluid mixer the particles initially tended to concentrate in one layer of liquid, which only slowly dispersed into the main body of the fluid. That concentrated polymer has a number of interesting properties.


Figure 2. Lifting a thick concentration of polymer from a bucket by hand.

For example it can be thick enough that one can grab it with one's fingers and lift it that way out of the bucket, as the picture above shows, or it can cause a unique problem in a mixing tank.

The polymer can wind up around the mixing paddle shaft and work its way up the shaft until it hits the retaining screw at the top. It then piles up at this point until it reaches a critical mass, when a tendril can be thrown out of the tank, through the centrifugal force exerted through rotation of the paddle shaft. The tendril falling outside the tank falls to the floor, which is lower than the fluid in the tank, and thus the concentrated layer of polymer is drawn up the inside of the tank, over the side and down the outside of the tank since it is still attached to the escaping tendril. The result clearly showed that liquid could flow uphill, when pulled by the cohesion inherent in the high concentration polymer.

This, in turn, gives either a disadvantage (if you are using this in a factory) or an advantage to the use of the polymer. The reason comes from the fluid nickname – Slippery Water.” The addition of the polymer, while reducing friction in the pipe, also reduces it between a person’s shoe and the floor, and thus it becomes a hazard in the workplace, since it increases the risk of slipping. It has the impressive title Anti Traction Mobility Denial System . We used to call it Banana water, but that seems to have faded from use.

The need to reach the very low concentrations of polymer that are all that is necessary to enhance jet cutting required a better way of mixing, The recommended answer was to briefly suspend the particles in a suspension of isopropyl alcohol (swirling it in a cup worked well) and then dumping it into the tank in a way that ensured that the individual prills were distributed away from one another. And while this worked, it was somewhat cumbersome and worked well only when mixing up individual batches of water – useful in a laboratory but not so much in a factory that must operate steadily for a full shift.

A number of different chemical liquid additives, most particularly polyacrylamides and derivatives of guar gum, have been tested, with the original work (carried out with the help of Dr Jack Zakin) being carried out in special section of the Baxter Springs plant where we could photograph jets at one-millionth of a second in order to study their structure. To do that we set the system up so that the jet was back-lit, so that we could determine how solid the core jet was, and used a high-speed strobe to illuminate the jet for the short-time needed to freeze the jet motion, leaving the camera shutter open for that time. This meant that the room was totally dark, and since the tests were carried out in the middle of summer, it made for an interesting couple of weeks.


Figure 3. Improved cohesion of a 30,000 psi jet when polymer is added (lower picture) the jet range shown in the picture is about 8 inches.

We also ran a pressure transducer across the different jets, at different standoff distances, so that, for the most promising additives, we could measure the differences in impact pressure and jet cohesion as the transducer moved away from the nozzle. The results were reported in the Proceedings of the 3rd ISJCT with the different chemicals tested ranked according to their ability to improve jet cohesion and reduce jet spread.


One of the problems with some of the additives is that they are temperature sensitive, and the jet was coming from the nozzle at temperatures between 95 and 115 deg Fahrenheit (it was a hot summer and the water reservoir was not chilled). This was not recognized at the time, and it did have some impact on the performance of some of the chemicals, which also showed a tendency to rapidly age once mixed, due to the storage conditions. Nevertheless the results showed that while Polyox was the best compound, there were liquid alternatives that also were effective, and the technology has since switched to liquid additives of which I will have more to say next time.

Zublin, C.W., "Water Jet Cleaning Speeds - Theoretical Determinations," 2nd U.S. Water Jet Conference, Rolla, MO, May, 1983, pp. 159 - 166.
Zakin, J.L., Summers, D.A., The Effect of Visco-Elastic Additives on Jet Structure," paper A4, 3rd International Symposium on Jet Cutting Technology, Chicago, IL, May, 1976, pp. A4-47 - A4-66.

Read more!

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Waterjetting 31d - thickening a waterjet to improve downstream pressure

There is a trick that one can learn while a teenager, which comes with the introduction “I so strong that I can blow a brick over!” Upon finding a suitable victim to impress, the brick is placed over a deflated balloon, which is then inflated, raising the brick which then, if suitably placed, topples onto its side – proving the strength of your lungs.

The critical part of the activity is to have the air that you blow be confined within the balloon, and equally exert pressure over the surface of the brick, so that a low pressure translates into a much more significant and powerful force. It is the confinement of the pressure that allows the build-up that moves the brick.

In most cases the use of high-pressure water as a cutting tool does not see much confinement of the water over the cutting process, with the water flowing into the cut, removing some material, and then flowing on out. Yet the water still has considerable energy as it leaves, and this means that the process is usually quite inefficient. How then can the contained energy in the jet be used in a secondary way to improve the removal efficiency of the process?

One answer to the question comes with the use of long-chain polymeric additives. These have recently seen a fair amount of publicity because of their use as the “slick water” components of the “slick-water-fracking” tools that have helped improve the production of oil and natural gas from long horizontal wells drilled into the hydrocarbon deposits in places such as the Bakken fields of North Dakota and the Barnett and Eagle Ford Shales in Texas. The long horizontal wells are separated into short intervals, within which the pressure within the well is raised until the surrounding rock cracks (fracks) with s series of cracks that extend out into the surrounding rock. The crack makes it easier for the hydrocarbons in the rock to escape and reach the well, improving the recovery to the point that the well can be economic to operate. The reason that the “slick water” is used is that the crack would normally close back up after the borehole pressure was lowered back down. In order to stop this happening the fluid in the well during the frack is made up with long-chain polymers and also contains grains of a sand or similar proppant. When the crack is formed the fluid in the well flows into the crack, carrying the sand with it, and this then holds the crack open when the pressure falls.

The polymer thickens the water which makes up most of the fracking fluid, so that it can carry more of the sand, and at the same time, the polymer reduces the friction of the water against the rock, so that it is easier for the water and sand to penetrate deeper into the cracks. Once the proppant particles catch against the sides of the crack they become held in place, while the fluid moves on and eventually returns back out of the well.

Back in the days when I was carrying out the research for my doctorate, I had used the long-chain polymer Polymerized ethylene oxide (Polyox) to reduce the friction in the delivery line from the pump to the nozzle. The increased cohesion of the jet (which I will cover in posts that follow this) meant that it would cut to a greater distance from the nozzle, with less decline in cutting power. However the increased cohesion of the jet had an additional benefit, which was noted by Chapman Young, as part of his development of tools for removing loose rock from around tunnels.

In a typical tunnel excavation, the miners drill a pattern of holes in the face of the tunnel, and then partially fill these with explosive, which is then set off in a controlled pattern of blasting. The central core of rock on the face is broken out by the explosive force, but some portion of the rock at the edge of the blast is only loosened from the solid, and still hangs in place. One of the more dangerous mining jobs (which I have done) is to take a long pry bar and insert this behind the loose pieces of rock around the opening, hoping to be able to wedge these loose, so that they no longer pose a risk to miners who then pass underneath.

Seeking to automate this process Dr Young and his colleagues tried using high-pressure waterjets to blast these lumps free from the wall. Subsequently investigators at Colorado School of Mines have shown that the jets give an improved cleaning of the wall, over other methods – but as normally applied they do not have the confined power to be able to get behind the block with sufficient confined force to be able to pry larger blocks free.

And this is where the balloon analogy comes in, because Dr Young realized that if he could increase the viscocity of the water in the stream sufficiently so that, for a short instance, it would be confined behind the block and could acquire some of the pressure from the following impacting jet, then enough pressure over a large enough area would provide the force needed to dislodge the block. He tried it, and it worked.

It is not, however, a simple process to carry out, since the jet path must be carefully aimed to ensure that there is enough confinement of the water behind the target block for pressure to be built up, and this requires that the jet contain a relatively high concentration of polymer. That in itself brings another problem, which can be anticipated by the “slick water” nickname. Where the water gets onto the floor the friction reduction properties mean that it makes it quite difficult to walk on the wetted rock. Now while that, in turn, opens up a new avenue for business (the chemical is sometimes referred to as Banana water in riot control) it makes it unpopular with those that have to work with it in the confines of a mining tunnel and so the technology has not caught on. But it does provide an introduction to the topic of different cutting fluids, which will be the next topic of discussion.

Read more!

Sunday, November 30, 2014

Waterjetting 27e - Borehole Back Pressure Effects

In the earlier posts on this chapter of waterjet technology I have dealt with the changes in cutting performance when a waterjet stream cuts in to material that is either under pressure, or contains internal stresses that may not be obvious at first glance. In this post I will focus, instead, on the changes in performance when the borehole becomes filled with water under pressure.


Figure 1. 12-inch cores of sandstone that have been drilled by the same jet drill, at the same speed, but at borehole pressures of 0, 500 psi, 1,000 psi, 1,500 psi and 2,000 psi. (Jet pump pressure 10,000 psi; 970 rpm; 40 inches/min ROP)

The water used in the test also contained a small amount of polyethylene oxide (Polyox) that, at the time, was the only polymer readily available to enhance jet performance under water, although there are now liquids such as Superwater that similarly help.

It can be seen that even the change in pressure to 500 psi is sufficient to dramatically shorten the distance that the jet cuts through the material on a single pass, and the range then only shortens a little as pressure further increases. But the hole drilled at 2,000 psi is barely large enough to let the high pressure lance and nozzle assembly pass.

First an explanation of the equipment that we used to run the tests. A triaxial cell was used as the basic vessel to hold the core. This is so-called since it allows pressure to be applied around the rock core, and also since the cap can slide within seals, axial pressure given the third of the orthogonal directions for loading.


Figure 2. Triaxial cell used for the drilling experiments.

A valve was fitted on the flow line of water out of the chamber (just above the pressure dial) and this controlled the fluid pressure in the cell. The diameter of the outer (reaming) jet was 0.04 inches, and the rapid decay in range with the increase in pressure led to a second experiment, to see how changing the diameter changed the results. The equipment was modified for this test, the feed pipe to the nozzle was bent, so that, as it made a single circuit over the underlying rock, it would trace out a circular path rather cut a single hole. Then the top of the sample was cut at an angle so that, with the rotation the distance from the jet to the target would vary and the range of the jet could be seen. (Figure 4).


Figure 3. Modified equipment to find the effective jet range against back pressure.

A simplified factorial experiment was run with three nozzle diameters and five back pressures, measuring the depth of cut into the sandstone in each case.


Figure 4. The resulting cut when a 0.03 inch diameter jet was rotated over sandstone with a 1,000 psi back pressure in the cell. The 10,000 psi jet was brought up to pressure with the jet at the greatest standoff (hole at the bottom) and the back pressure was set before making a single pass over the sample. The depth of cut was averaged over several readings made along its length.

The data was then plotted (with the curve smoothed here for simplicity in discussion).


Figure 5. A plot of range of jet cutting ability as a function of hole back pressure for three different nozzle diameters.

The graph shows that, for this set of conditions, the larger the jet the better, and that the first 500 psi of back pressure has an immediate effect on jet cutting effectiveness. Jet size should be at least 0.064 inches when drilling against back pressure in the hole. There was a significant improvement in cutting ability when the polymer (at 300 ppm) was subsequently added to the water, in a later series of tests. The small number of tests carried out, however, were too small a sample to provide more than guidance as to concentration since all three levels tested (100, 200 and 300 ppm) all showed considerably improved depths of cut (increasing to a depth of almost 2 inches against a back pressure of 2,500 psi) when contrasted with the performance levels shown above. The polymer tests were carried out with a jet nozzle diameter of 0.064 inches.

There are two parts to the effect of the borehole pressure. The first is simply one of increasing the resistance of the water to jet penetration, and lowering the effective jet pressure (since that is effectively the jet pressure less the borehole pressure).

It is important to recognize that it is not just the drop in effective pressure that causes the effect. To check that this was the case a hole was drilled with the same conditions otherwise as the left-hand rock sample in Figure 1, except that the jet pressure was dropped to 5,000 psi. Thus the differential pressure of the jet across the nozzle was less than that in the case of the other four rock samples shown in Figure 1. Yet the hole was of the same approximate irregular geometry as that shown by the left-hand core of Figure 1 even with the lower differential pressure with the prominent cone cut ahead of the bit that is not evident in the other cases.

Mike Hood has shown the effect of loss in cutting range by using back-lit shadow images of a jet at different back pressures.


Figure 6. Illustration of the effect of fluid back pressure, the shadow image of the jet shows how back pressure reduces the range.

As mentioned above, the effects extend beyond reducing the jet range, and lowering the jet differential pressure. The increased confinement on the rock will compress the grains of the rock more tightly together, making it more difficult for the pressurized water to penetrate into the rock structure. This combines with the higher pressure required to grow the cracks to effectively reduce the ability of the jet to penetrate into the rock.

At the same time, if you listen as the back pressure is increased (we used a Lichtarowicz Cell the increasing pitch of the sound shows (as does the damage induced) that the collapse of the cavitation bubbles generated around the edges of the submerged jet is becoming more intense as the pressure increases. I have discussed how this can be used as a benefit in breaking up rock in an earlier post.

Read more!

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Waterjetting 16b - Optimum Abrasive Feed Rate and Depth

The post that I wrote last week was focused on the misperception that you need to add more abrasive to an abrasive waterjet if you wish to cut through thicker material. This is wrong on a number of counts, but most particularly because a good operator will have tuned the nozzle to achieve the best cutting jet, based on pressure and abrasive feed rate (AFR) regardless of target material. What the operator may change is the operating pressure (which would change the optimum AFR) and the traverse speed since these control the depth and quality of the cut that the jet makes.

But, before leaving the topic, I would like to discuss, in a little more detail, the concept of the optimal amount of abrasive that one should use with a given jet, and what happens as that feed rate is changed. As I mentioned last time, because of differences in the shapes of the mixing chambers of the nozzles supplied by different manufacturers, the specific sizes and optimal flow rates will differ from nozzle to nozzle but the overall conclusions remain the same.

Last time I pointed out that the driving waterjet had to break up within the mixing chamber in order to properly mix with the abrasive and to bring this up to a maximum speed before the mix left the focusing tube. Where the driving jet is too large then this breakup is not complete and the mixing is not efficient. As a result the jet that comes out of the end is more diffuse and the abrasive will not have reached the full velocity possible. However, if the incoming waterjet is made smaller for the same AFR and other mixing chamber geometries, then the cutting performance will decline.


Figure 1. Effect of increase in jet pressure when cutting aluminum with an AFR of 1.7 lb/minute (after Hashish, M., "Abrasive Jets," Section 4, in Fluid Jet Technology- Fundamentals and Applications, Waterjet Technology Association, St. Louis, MO, 1991.)

For a similar reason adding a polymer to the jet fluid should only be carried out with some care for the consequences. Long-chain polymers can give a jet increased cohesion and this can, at high enough concentrations, inhibit jet breakup in the mixing chamber thus reducing the effectiveness of mixing in the chamber.


Figure 2. The effect of changing cutting fluid on AWJ performance (after Dr Hashish ibid)

Polyox, (polyethylene oxide) is an extremely effective polymer for increasing jet performance by cohering the jet and reducing the friction losses between the pump and the nozzle. However, as the graph shows, adding it to some abrasive systems will reduce performance since the more coherent jet makes it more difficult for the abrasive to mix and accelerate to full velocity. At lower concentrations the polymer allows the jet to breakup, but keeps the slugs of water together making energy transfer more efficient. Higher velocity abrasive means that less is required to achieve the same cutting performance as Walters and Saunders showed.


Figure 3. Effect of adding polymer in reducing the amount of abrasive required to cut stainless steel (after Walters, C.L., Saunders, D.H., "DIAJET Cutting for Nuclear Decommissioning," Paper J2, 10th International Symposium on Jet Cutting Technology, Amsterdam, Netherlands, October, 1990, pp. 427 - 440.)

At low levels of abrasive feed Dr Hashish has shown that increasing the amount of abrasive in the feed increases cutting performance.


Figure 4. Effect of increase in AFR on depth of cut in mild steel at a feed rate of 6 inches/min (After Dr. Hashish ibid), waterjet diameter 0.01 inches.

However, as the abrasive flow rate continues to increase the cutting performance reaches a plateau and can decline, as Dr. Hashish illustrated. An AFR of 20 gm/sec is equivalent to a feed of 2.6 lb/minute.


Figure 5. The effect of higher AFR on cutting depth at 3 jet pressures on a mild steel target (after Dr. Hashish ibid)

Note that in this case the nozzle geometry was not optimized for operation at the highest jet pressure. More visibly we ran a series of cuts across a granite sample, where the only thing that changed between cuts was that we increased the abrasive feed rate in cuts from the left to the right. It can be seen that beyond a certain AFR the jet starts to cut to a shallower depth.


Figure 6. Successive cuts made into a granite block at increasing AFR from the left to the right.

Interestingly the optimum feed rate doesn’t just depend on the pressure and water flow rate (waterjet orifice size) of the system. Faber and Oweinah have shown that as the feed particle size gets larger, so the optimum AFR reduces.


Figure 7. Optimal Abrasive feed rate as a function of particle size (after Faber, K., Oweinah, H., "Influence of Process Parameters on Blasting Performance with the Abrasive Jet," paper 25, 10th International Symposium on Jet Cutting Technology, Amsterdam, October, 1990, pp. 365 - 384.)

The process of finding an optimal feed rate for a system is thus controlled by the design of the mixing chamber based on the relative position of the abrasive feed tube and the size of the waterjet orifice. This controls how well the abrasive that is fed into the system can mix with the jet and acquire the velocity that it needs for most effective cutting. Then, as the above plot shows, the optimal AFR is also influenced by the size of the particles that are being fed into the system, since as the particles become larger beyond a certain size, so the cutting effectiveness declines.

Part of the reason for this is that, as the AFR increases so there is an increased risk of particle to particle impact breaking the particles down into smaller sizes. (And an earlier post showed that smaller particles cut less effectively – as does figure 7 above). We screened the particles that came from several different designs of AWJ nozzle assemblies capturing them after they left the nozzle but without further impact, so that the size range is indicative of that which a target material would see,

The table is a summary of some of the results and it shows results for a feed that began at 250 microns giving the percentage of the particles that survived at larger than 100 microns.


Figure 8. Percentage of the 250 micron sized feed that survives at above 100 micron for differing jet conditions. (the numbers are averaged from several tests).

It can be seen that when the feed rate rises to 1.5 lb a minute that there is a drop in abrasive size at higher jet pressures, and this is likely to be due to the increased interaction with particles. Since cutting effectiveness is controlled by particle size, count and velocity the only slightly greater amount of particles that survive above 100 microns at 1.5 lb/minute relative to those that survive at 1 lb/minute suggest that spending the money to increase the AFR above the optimal value (in this case around 1 lb/min) is a wasted investment.

It is therefore important to tune the system to ensure that, for each jet pressure and nozzle design that is used, that the AFR has been optimized.

Read more!

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Me, This Week in Energy, and why Halliburton might refuse EPA

This afternoon I was an invited guest on “This Week in Energy” with Nikki Gordon-Bloomfield and Bob Tregelus. Among other things we talked about the fracking process that is being used to help produce the natural gas from shales such as the Marcellus and Haynesville. In the course of the discussion I was asked why of the nine fracking companies that EPA asked for their formulae, only Halliburton had refused the request. Bob pointed out that they were going to be subpoenaed and thus would have to give up the information anyway. I have discussed some of the problems of stimulating a well with hydraulic fracturing, both real and less so, on this site last March when the public perception of the technology began to change.

In the possible explanation I am going to give, you need to know that this is purely a supposition and the chemicals that I am going to mention are put forward out of my own head, as it were. I have no real clue as to why Halliburton are acting the way that they are, and am only building a hypothesis that might only through some slight possibility have any approximate relation to the truth.


In the evolution of the technology that has made production of the gas shales possible several different technologies had to be developed. The rock (which is actually a mudstone) has a very poor natural permeability. I.e. it is very difficult for fluid to flow through the rock, because the passage ways are very narrow and not very well connected. Thus the normal vertical wells would not produce very much oil or gas when drilled through the shale reservoir, certainly not enough to be profitable. The first beneficial development was, therefore, the ability to drill horizontally after the well had reached the reservoir depth. Once this was possible, then the length of the well that was exposed to the reservoir (which might be only 30 ft thick) would increase from that 30 ft to perhaps 10,000 ft. Since the amount of fluid flowing into the well is a function of the length of the exposed well in the rock, when the reservoir rock has a normal permeability this is enough to increase production significantly (as for example in the new wells in Saudi Arabia).

However when the rock has a very poor permeability even the long wells will only very slowly accumulate fluid from the surrounding rock, since there are no easy passages to the well through that rock. Thus the next benefit that was needed was the ability to crack the rock around the well. This is known as hydraulic fracturing or hydrofracking for short. In modern wells, by isolating and then pressurizing different segments of the well in turn, these cracks can be created (when the pressure inside the well exceeds the rock strength) at regular intervals (say 30 to 120 ft apart) along the length of the borehole.

The cracks are controlled in length (since if they go outside the reservoir all the fluid can drain away through the other end of the cracks, not to the well). But the problem is that once the crack is made, the pressure inside the well is lowered and the equipment moved to the next segment. Without any other changes as the pressure comes off the crack it will close back up, and there will not be much gain from the effort. So to keep the crack open what the industry calls a proppant, but you or I might just call it a carefully sized sand, is mixed with the fracking fluid before it is injected into the well.

As a result, when the cracks open in the rock, and the fracking fluid flows into the crack, the sand is carried with it, and is then trapped in the crack, holding it open after the pressure is lowered. A passage then exists for the gas or oil to travel to the well and production of most of the rock volume becomes possible.

Well that was when the development of the gas shale deposits began, however it had not been going on very long when it was noticed that the sand was not flowing easily into the fractures, and without enough sand being carried far enough back into the cracks, production wasn’t nearly as good as it should have been.

At this point another development was needed. This came about when an additional chemical – what is known as a long-chain polymer (typically a polyacrylamide) - was added to the fracking fluid. These fluids are known as Friction Reducing Agents (FRAs) because they tend to make water stick together a bit, and create extremely slippery surfaces when they coat them. By adding these FRAs to the fracking fluid, the crack walls became slipperier and the sand particles could thus travel deeper into the cracks, holding them open more effectively and increasing gas production. The fluids were given the generic name “slick water”, so that the current state-of-the-art is a horizontal well that has had a multi-fracture, slickwater-hydrofracking operation run on it.

But the problems of the wells are not over. As I noted in my post yesterday, the mudstones contain a significant amount of clays. And the problem when clays get wet is that they get softer and clay particles can break away from the wall of the fracture (slaking). Over the different gas shale deposits the problems are not consistent, since each shale is made of a different set of constituent rock types and clays. But overall the problem that is now being evidenced, as Art Berman has commented a number of times, is that the wells are losing production faster and earlier than predicted, so that they cannot meet the overall targets that make the well profitable. Instead of the well lasting perhaps a decade, they are losing perhaps 60% of the flow in the first year, and are no longer worth operating after maybe three years.

With all that as background, here is a hypothesis to explain Halliburton’s actions. It is quite possible that the well failures are due to the clay failure in the shale reducing the crack effectiveness. Clay content failure can do this, once the fracking fluid has cracked and wetted it, by a long term softening (which will allow the walls of the crack to fold around the proppant particles, and close the crack as the walls move in), or simply swelling into some of the crack space, with the same effect. Alternately the clay particles may slake and break away from the walls of the crack, and over time build up small dams along the crack path, again blocking the fluid flow through the crack – any one of these mechanisms explains the production falls that are being seen in the industry.

So lets say that Halliburton has realized the problem and, for merely the sake of a discussable solution, changes the polymer that they use from a pure polyacrylamide (PA) to include polyethylene oxide (PO). One thing that PO does at much lower concentrations than PA is that it stops the fracking fluid from wetting the shale, and interacting with the clay. Because it is (or at least was when we did this) much more expensive than PA there is not normally any reason to use PO in the fracking fluid.

But let us say that Halliburton have tried this, and it works. Because it is a step change in the process (in the same way as horizontal drilling; fracking; and slick water use were each, in turn) then the company selling the new idea has a tremendous commercial advantage. They can promise you that your well will stay in production long enough for you to make a profit, while the competition cannot.

The world of hydrofracking contractors is small and engineers move around, so that commercial advantage does not last very long, and word gets out as to how it was done. But that takes time, first to find out what is causing the problem, then what the answer is in general, and then what the answer is in detail. Each of those steps might take a competitor a year. That gives you three years of advantage, when you can charge higher rates, and possibly put some of that competition out of business.

The problem is that if the competition sees that you have put PO in your fluid, instead of PA then they can immediately go and look up what difference that makes to the fluid. Knowing that it stops wetting immediately gets them past stages one and two and cuts the term of your commercial advantage from three years to one.

Would you want to give that up if, by lawyering and all those fancy tricks they get up to in Washington you could get the time that you have to release the content postponed by at least a year? Likely not, and since dragging out the process can extend the period of your commercial advantage, the longer you can keep kicking the ball down the street the greater your advantage, and the more benefit.

And I re-iterate this is purely a hypothesis that I came up with, and I have no connections that would suggest that this has any connection to reality.

Read more!